1
0
mirror of https://gitlab.com/Anson-Projects/projects.git synced 2025-06-16 15:06:53 +00:00
Projects/posts/2025-04-25/aerospace_structural_design_dataset.csv
2025-05-11 18:18:59 +00:00

90 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

1Material TypeE (GPa)νρ (kg/m³)Tensile Strength (MPa)Youngs ModulusAltitude (m)Temperature (°C)Pressure (Pa)Operational Life (years)Wing Span (m)Fuselage Length (m)Structural Thickness (mm)Structural ShapeLoad DistributionVibration DampingComputational TimeWeight EfficiencyDurabilityQuantum Algorithm TypeNumber of IterationsOptimization Time (sec)
2Aluminum185.696745872169230.30770910768930672730.7104533475731423.889662876148691.1729928844621315599.655147919875-57.4316753428427148360.107451154333733.20071473861176564.898149342856713.688270591376993Taperedpoint loadLowShortExcellentLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1568146.8483625712404
3Titanium59.8523963085512850.30910659765117471969.6701047524516467.442225002757788.1618601896965712086.883847255816-40.72602152301445168254.9428312123236.62883737585493562.937733888978369.550246323730573Cylindricalpoint loadHighLongPoorHighShark Optimizer1764107.07157146961171
4Carbon Fiber136.373918068723130.346932398077179463659.13911868068961.163422557167755.8991662795867819366.24386815015-43.5763296690442161654.152332612262736.0608142809666456.8129678619963065.026259803862095TapereddistributedLowLongGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1707148.14485133157285
5Aluminum103.14046886715670.31108038420936073377.90415465026041432.133209838821453.7181234840476715975.653098448489-54.26445040826743143375.99817523172558.470930929206230.4771160630965459.812850176901676CylindricaldistributedHighLongGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic139472.46312572695285
6Aluminum136.732380125051520.30817431061506891859.52780678290971448.294058914661786.937768816898286948.7164403823535-41.03878977021339100397.40351998263151.2165685191522630.51503783531071410.85505636634123Taperedpoint loadHighMediumPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic63072.55489227802586
7Aluminum142.82932617070480.34586928006813613835.2676659121353289.394859933153195.375208586356566431.227665179744-56.159318961767795176977.51455534683120.0190776311969565.651693419940129.711056981697059RectangularuniformModerateLongGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic84566.4723509826728
8Aluminum180.052887938303370.326059540957946872165.6654187122276394.823615146579497.2343522348280212975.196444997844-40.785178256254122496.841817797322225.64143930280390654.934765575285038.580532219920899CylindricaldistributedLowShortPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic144357.438959985958036
9Carbon Fiber95.465679321469250.33647914464435232381.1918865021908918.337526256085177.544905626441086402.932149851687-59.083534493517206116094.727738018482327.64111417257959545.865979693232076.396295653522422Rectangularpoint loadModerateMediumPoorMediumShark Optimizer1304136.93256390334258
10Titanium193.332110001009650.31562232012523173843.9773642084233832.552218300218781.4032233584659516974.39460676098-53.134688761511086135539.805023324332134.65705187546442539.97182120919076514.578870208967704TapereduniformHighLongGoodMediumShark Optimizer1124107.67952920733637
11Carbon Fiber125.093394978844840.32706954487159153931.5677282158986312.1837676600947695.1143817251208618428.346563804655-59.113182716605884189515.15909886753723.5587440028885139.8993702507291612.239644803414784RectangulardistributedLowMediumExcellentLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1195128.01889520720465
12Titanium99.761972003796670.342199714942696853802.2136633007171337.031298685643453.2196532191904219718.0400014506-45.667662622288994139306.786264620143837.8746791071895949.99573633928764614.680648659535029RectangularuniformLowMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic144279.20082571877944
13Aluminum143.31258736663090.339932199759266032850.5786094242585305.129394172037495.476546377047245193.101067257328-43.569465368927624123778.860478374342058.87107448202054664.76364487759912.510552252342098Rectangularpoint loadHighLongExcellentMediumShark Optimizer541104.87086654280625
14Aluminum173.972083169246620.32979278466044114088.6946641398861214.61278455323561.2136942098372514942.473259534878-58.933154133216995128046.049102704773421.71371416274529867.395877369302246.02060881973955Taperedpoint loadLowLongPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic179860.48475132088802
15Carbon Fiber164.392801077640.301606844588134863323.080303973813969.019540169700870.3797465800683316548.358714079353-52.32338621879984122355.921544727033230.28817207039537665.389143300247818.442654498895124Taperedpoint loadModerateMediumGoodLowShark Optimizer103758.774870860473825
16Titanium91.15917245576060.300210298724513551664.390825278095261.246867551851987.614045381274767737.665305560045-46.40778002720175126644.236630431862345.9447935609493266.083938233280045.928445821198167Taperedpoint loadLowShortPoorMediumShark Optimizer139672.30942096323649
17Carbon Fiber165.10222879163040.30082217105833743555.2175899344197831.521338732233988.0593851315067315200.805232377954-56.678938895369924187245.154962931933541.17502856758209659.84647730193671611.369122049991104Rectangularpoint loadHighLongPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic118167.18012070543091
18Titanium183.852203932940230.31948163024747282140.532584432867402.7853030225603652.326491957597199470.54768089762-43.50481992939302194043.182136931513845.66898691977091635.758659245918647.508387097294733Rectangularpoint loadHighMediumExcellentLowShark Optimizer76291.06840119767335
19Carbon Fiber97.736490001812570.34652518149729631650.9898639307981412.759090526918359.52969890805569473.487152567275-48.69266879369785100593.882732553172953.8850082593999167.590101056946995.915049433139105Taperedpoint loadLowMediumExcellentLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1541130.16451419467
20Titanium103.321008347962870.32516164166379652063.066243161847731.244456691292887.3909953548515518773.927987827636-51.635418720272136000.45131982923255.7102744499113335.964611974223216.202030045517514Rectangularpoint loadHighShortExcellentLowShark Optimizer1178109.9248169510528
21Carbon Fiber126.670863832625120.31849864507536152748.53506889175331431.743191082091266.2613955957439610000.458614177083-42.72863794266303160618.245641492863236.12386408501599568.646753509481367.9588951429252806RectangulardistributedHighShortPoorHighShark Optimizer674144.71471248891976
22Carbon Fiber65.836400462452740.332104392906976242288.82335945084921402.92334662886263.3096055390407512889.236306517234-44.748384737640826103901.365290638542155.59975894880335550.265988352001613.092362933884004TapereduniformLowLongExcellentLowShark Optimizer1466143.485302485745
23Aluminum76.073395928149920.337822055167810943894.8878432032566879.849836310161857.3306826525131718175.65280786523-45.65945623655695148914.57495601043752.7716272771602830.3295112769873436.363333735735451RectangularuniformHighMediumExcellentLowShark Optimizer763114.57785713385437
24Aluminum114.304645624923210.313648983750168642853.34715340188361186.498515800794259.9426274153011515227.771507441645-46.325477400382574149505.710959715863555.9971047755758253.074274141203712.042902290161347TapereduniformLowLongExcellentMediumShark Optimizer123463.30789714731612
25Aluminum155.300141257264730.34630451716222782372.8284378673681287.36428411389886.186918463062619429.82668906438-56.192926682953505180798.828178862922652.8141436365731156.232671131330015.447753801464143CylindricaluniformHighMediumExcellentHighShark Optimizer1716127.07984141251384
26Titanium89.681851814328070.346018785451676363467.49418422326151244.68329344612275.083987493945097648.5411822589795-53.2587376814376169678.541081134323355.9567262435759451.8025931699386.507240669764442TapereddistributedModerateShortExcellentLowShark Optimizer1800106.0349869724827
27Carbon Fiber94.9413266282750.32923414823130941984.0315169111295451.3991905315430776.2555094332468918675.48532861378-41.92134845163533186516.573431621332235.75326550728719648.0157994892450913.666356250759645Taperedpoint loadLowMediumPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1481140.0233447736726
28Titanium199.817577596815140.317304274476396251520.9326830665884887.669818583358571.5779742427210716849.923868198835-43.141478528705484127924.24019077223937.38934848600399641.31306347834766511.617647747105028RectangulardistributedModerateLongPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1937107.71802469964831
29Carbon Fiber126.15585481494020.312204597902202341766.14223573201981483.216172175003386.996524462782976000.560641294601-45.22842906320757182374.73553510963331.34503712033267743.271057312889416.3104386120918035Cylindricalpoint loadLowMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic156762.49753806139737
30Titanium90.491208563966420.31105945561933962246.090732707651961.739552723203151.93646785594156909.513172344643-40.471672166170094120719.485154981362735.28814303383434550.922336889393218.077167277113304Rectangularpoint loadHighMediumPoorLowShark Optimizer117869.96057682332706
31Carbon Fiber174.183023235616820.34886508622686022110.44140688673221415.844769028497286.9716863999210815470.964231330086-48.66796601545295170774.81306600753249.4915740815481237.35793980208363512.23262699413218CylindricaldistributedModerateShortExcellentHighShark Optimizer1688113.78608840480152
32Carbon Fiber50.103247927798460.31985380991740113454.203405489341436.46356347673787.398025630942513293.297069881495-56.033926491614785107368.453445763953253.6566246820026649.5999295339753913.776411710333175CylindricaluniformModerateLongGoodLowShark Optimizer151266.20427445707013
33Titanium102.593703211581330.31383652492030133698.0010546970771031.289319788936267.822331266597918551.41433765254-48.959965085013394199753.231214564562939.3340954532325969.10424439480126.166558380245696TapereddistributedModerateMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic59986.20459461383635
34Carbon Fiber179.86018377648950.32121994851657684051.815453630391350.327291137723371.026598860127937317.398454824679-46.00713854401302130432.428645558512638.4352633735498248.391603139266912.13650477461984CylindricaldistributedLowLongPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic136770.39894477480988
35Aluminum180.317173708586130.323989706352766144236.440887210955958.054792905962790.1869460059168117721.35467467908-42.842938469918366138251.06867347742759.01942080420868662.6327269734708958.801667918699188Cylindricalpoint loadHighMediumGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic109465.43744200049852
36Titanium83.947427018117070.346297604138414761620.54083439743641410.305366474637172.458022387882075974.708676638895-40.830608758035396196996.04011350713349.1769580530283253.1164346664817512.563119463106682RectangularuniformHighLongGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1391137.70287344490055
37Carbon Fiber153.79026704500990.34293342492286982045.35994321626531385.520090053625461.914107003858397609.827125359874-58.14729096847522159994.095907037932041.96931322951762452.367718763657395.5222071692582775TapereddistributedLowMediumExcellentMediumShark Optimizer735118.6915748127189
38Aluminum197.820964520498480.31199104434132893375.48918804584364.647807549755962.4831785045878719962.628912373224-53.29185042634573148172.10774594462146.0716574627289232.807912801405788.04504780546391Rectangularpoint loadModerateShortPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic135570.41310363401095
39Carbon Fiber96.497745743386870.32172344674848253611.406616621056325.708840321835662.642194343191739786.200543337738-55.01831751744858189546.536231367442147.1777299368693535.9812769198156111.272163084709497RectangularuniformHighLongPoorHighShark Optimizer1537115.93701177580775
40Carbon Fiber67.193682201375310.31526213854106893360.8395808477903732.468387525029685.885234310169315536.035015799269-57.45037399033869103369.012469805733356.6823690530698660.828382049514298.793757771476947Taperedpoint loadLowShortGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1433108.24052665875041
41Aluminum145.96915924730580.32798379006480143047.0471882975553726.506591216006389.153341706023817223.092355193023-59.63576334379074137622.916198729862038.91948585708722441.487764072314985.12701814075527TapereduniformHighShortGoodLowShark Optimizer1297123.545799633798
42Titanium181.892512061738220.30452805937043862172.1416267134581138.694918829658778.1439423644708518492.477449297206-56.53532506341871148901.729448244853148.3376405293734169.948813224698417.7962542726683335Rectangularpoint loadModerateShortPoorMediumShark Optimizer1673130.23599876249048
43Aluminum180.408329051498950.33585465922670013779.3050792128631172.922158501782290.4028324899545917556.736668685626-58.215594813308456137763.0175233353355.0418905555109669.0524223651264314.281592330016922TapereduniformHighShortExcellentMediumShark Optimizer1058127.95688319796898
44Titanium139.362048238865530.31006908119865234106.413314134352968.827747176665355.177196621560927122.928541049403-53.213857781209214165453.967809208262043.57665272459135557.5058271358940949.682589900981457TapereddistributedLowMediumGoodLowShark Optimizer65690.94844860339671
45Aluminum51.810172493735060.33526057102534552650.0124950999593933.488821388764773.6697180373843412110.296660994027-52.97132452015937109136.383127787542127.91529283713796530.306232387564486.8265145781461145RectangulardistributedLowMediumGoodLowShark Optimizer98267.1710167138295
46Carbon Fiber165.541286902021850.33468205548065113000.742299803105710.781301251780293.7287507628138910280.128630580095-48.95614388650211124515.458245558243124.75420848693223554.4082865587980967.162245260464161TapereddistributedHighShortPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic860108.83157338856557
47Carbon Fiber75.526368233044760.340154624089326342028.1682066038461128.378863775802579.6109621716741311035.915529704715-54.00550478062596174316.021293016032836.5760006534237831.62039014216041711.014452180626567Taperedpoint loadHighMediumPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic73481.91398929192813
48Aluminum134.24458152438710.33966252274789383213.3167597173288842.363245507294181.8223659441944715542.71059503579-58.37640252071766134366.92320803622028.43052119906658662.88520462056868612.591542248026117Taperedpoint loadModerateLongPoorLowShark Optimizer159082.87443305515785
49Carbon Fiber51.925898689871340.32639820780473083922.946353396984483.7174562905836496.4687050703133816843.764779349054-57.479913608505555178008.57250329082845.0507111018130152.451199943482755.431629480563175TapereddistributedLowMediumPoorHighShark Optimizer925139.55570121612305
50Aluminum52.395842686654410.33406469568700172963.7794095371771136.636404086637464.60668296722527705.364079862682-48.13611673605301105603.540825092662549.0816393907948231.339947260371917.280312441015119RectangulardistributedHighLongPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic80973.3023656715142
51Carbon Fiber67.124196048854640.349398283151576342646.2996146619453770.690787108997195.2536498246858218238.298468368568-50.39910153432608141906.42971030322326.20890467180372262.2292357665914310.024608673320618Rectangularpoint loadHighShortPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic1244113.95656958889435
52Titanium125.05505207633870.32616079726833292645.0333577480761158.152474191511857.8563017374636512984.628009003696-51.464052028780955195651.360068060143647.7008555918464644.83799988205261410.377837987060058Taperedpoint loadLowLongPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1004134.25045202845445
53Aluminum106.595971733691470.305200875662840932264.5563629256712864.400643925219853.9235296717289417000.188166578708-49.30703328992954113215.008169288722323.62761580003192660.231261495461811.395836224702238RectangulardistributedModerateMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1403148.71885519164908
54Carbon Fiber76.771398808944870.322883979587962834488.694619032443851.99485559832270.019218647696976991.4387878250345-46.73002893677631124068.245940569632946.8576359771599668.896766371139625.344333864801799TapereduniformLowLongExcellentLowShark Optimizer97360.18465465088313
55Carbon Fiber166.625954029428070.313456175616551541622.4188456010431178.454679282711887.571620190211796496.415503073929-50.295794871642926139673.23331806552446.0328447118819534.7968264175946710.444322753597827Taperedpoint loadLowMediumGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic558111.82440330975172
56Carbon Fiber103.175462475766140.321141190615396033580.8718343627593921.273637981625851.1544426907704617763.3555582122-45.51593734921981182848.757676690353740.7086940596436261.5532074357686411.67580067141912TapereddistributedHighShortPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic88971.70554771821288
57Titanium119.786593121904290.322027631849252372633.07270485548451386.42925370637391.4848933542981213027.527204254908-58.6709913401147131722.586650428042631.57067289392788560.7102954840366511.001914083861738Taperedpoint loadModerateMediumPoorMediumShark Optimizer72857.87785554951081
58Carbon Fiber64.73375313990950.319096966224565071710.77117420074251116.22433277737294.5918937068232618630.828820971074-49.54321187274624140880.154865801223344.24589018819321535.068606861033139.930351982443662RectangulardistributedHighMediumExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic125062.39023637596573
59Titanium157.13665253763560.337781136190041964229.2027955971481008.343499539435567.2694675413126511875.459658007705-47.26416892525209158625.79286033363555.3744833651979557.53237389794378513.725027226744846RectangulardistributedModerateMediumExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic126895.69211755015316
60Carbon Fiber96.253528088929580.33403313631506053832.486081712602579.729882425567780.16529737711887190.744253400046-58.649408845821426124270.029533664332838.7888204540813664.599130252855428.5736110339123Cylindricalpoint loadLowMediumExcellentMediumShark Optimizer78667.10415210554338
61Titanium125.495818547575680.30184956257612811989.1734798654365518.051933546115875.200191448103449020.01724669529-52.79323553442098183726.163445854122055.6856863098957158.4808986426271514.600653945697252CylindricaluniformModerateMediumGoodHighShark Optimizer755117.73648649644136
62Titanium79.786770289327460.308960322288736043329.2905176778951256.822947889272972.1578865143119314371.929990655526-44.05166669513029144302.98813176683144.0136829271295166.2062756808276710.429486165318567Rectangularpoint loadLowShortGoodLowShark Optimizer189555.141667030479894
63Carbon Fiber174.58403521980530.331129168962652764301.732871849848549.472780392139456.741964904054579426.797302187802-56.97075114852104120238.364958446823452.414739724210159.15707202127279612.497721685851827RectangulardistributedModerateLongPoorHighShark Optimizer193972.3663482379493
64Carbon Fiber145.70995926527280.344835135460562163870.516310149971103.963886240885683.315069803570058580.075154748785-58.316830925257385139575.788881990832931.0867895497815764.7976919142682811.303787498352008Cylindricalpoint loadHighShortPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic99498.5768274353511
65Titanium62.3526039281182850.338066823742256832756.9915996976871120.921640070022582.003872752349485216.132976166924-47.68758944534671181099.049508676283252.4557669428166953.2742022478186649.712069365189631RectangularuniformModerateLongExcellentHighShark Optimizer58061.7731919120438
66Aluminum141.937511296882120.326832703128487172936.11151143831971153.331164186790693.566002553214477128.339269199193-55.48393041486737131970.970974163123424.14939569265311547.7628276742982869.210452512591086TapereddistributedModerateShortGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic159551.452166808289505
67Carbon Fiber80.111192066099430.321425820779292272780.959556192543293.623092404697897.1672950545421714708.638971238977-41.62487786940113143689.051434635422540.56024114160861.405775734375313.166632656263959Rectangularpoint loadModerateMediumPoorHighShark Optimizer831126.86057157156615
68Aluminum64.923047024269780.340784847298014341530.47643334540661312.281558051725653.0560135085033514262.350117018757-47.226391365644176180417.576136337773330.0378226539119648.6833571230638114.681935967626739RectangulardistributedHighMediumPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic110184.01353425744054
69Carbon Fiber120.731613319681060.309163221668826151924.3483516533702806.301040204556162.45885736057160619741.455801564058-45.174906886232286145163.254074161762331.1607366305014548.799436111083676.747584948497522Cylindricalpoint loadModerateLongExcellentHighShark Optimizer953121.447874572892
70Aluminum83.311665576972770.349903965349138652531.42672194753871443.006200544485684.3325435769750418259.95440369423-40.02748539344467168238.467360319483656.3134822540332955.11312710941662410.321809275902819Rectangularpoint loadLowShortGoodLowShark Optimizer123993.69451577385689
71Titanium68.29877800099540.339284958069097142066.2404785057811446.14511110012870.776536450069336071.200278298396-54.743288070763846122164.363906505682734.0648183486942361.003494114122566.798012909150933Cylindricalpoint loadModerateLongExcellentLowShark Optimizer73797.38853897247955
72Carbon Fiber181.057701119598080.32002860859352964322.098351215337775.337634414903759.99828950617118346.319941714093-43.61098151450741163364.781049617742636.7157785461662440.7877659827447310.809703985386053RectangularuniformModerateShortGoodLowShark Optimizer1663144.36523752594871
73Carbon Fiber199.323318584448660.323467240827973573641.35929435735914.874818195055570.12820591287739471.04950912469-57.88165586225057102917.227465410762954.0694305245470967.952676044953938.603210229781345Rectangularpoint loadHighMediumGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic1866128.12058805649917
74Aluminum193.812780820160190.31985837484385363107.523429895602351.848647807898592.0903133650368511572.685577560882-59.83909144111157186846.30339524243641.3889129171186930.0127676828077710.869309077790453Taperedpoint loadModerateLongExcellentMediumShark Optimizer1679130.78437675187058
75Aluminum158.042811547539260.330813627599646442181.82150490679031387.506064248563275.0695346781463716022.430938517125-41.855856336011506129574.307892757662523.16939194734060766.533845042777538.99118465569181CylindricaluniformLowLongGoodHighShark Optimizer191463.81812421794935
76Aluminum123.004639787886520.335862293277911954298.405766018375282.521240740098987.1787431970854212006.848061767763-44.009619917183535145311.137551855763728.16349100578550644.1159452969457613.295317472826362CylindricaluniformHighShortPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic1505103.34248167878721
77Carbon Fiber157.249828102702370.327644240375156553997.6643604237981161.74317781904483.235680252919614777.163141768651-42.83664359993419179565.248147222972529.86508736337665634.9296221777194811.89974562572987Rectangularpoint loadLowMediumExcellentHighShark Optimizer1049134.16263742144548
78Aluminum199.798735626426830.338030791501857664155.8480786336031047.753956852849896.0039837376046110661.533557527062-55.046293817026466135523.915675291853850.908255821066461.618074934090168.58993668384335Rectangularpoint loadModerateMediumGoodLowShark Optimizer96081.88715670615426
79Carbon Fiber51.628750076736230.33429059732863162918.839606894168432.223948776251297.04581492735566765.488962142561-58.56350200026297136899.075576515232724.78062083456275751.0125754121266114.880442216015128Rectangularpoint loadHighMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic812142.45243956038541
80Titanium102.570248856722540.34840512376729554401.5752238872341371.289537502365698.4528391286118115413.802583061055-55.461850649184385163609.720595875433121.88415164173555347.4210769046642210.660588818362577Cylindricalpoint loadLowMediumGoodMediumShark Optimizer960138.89526786823666
81Carbon Fiber166.794269482691220.33351271623179763496.2237501589451078.669775284348478.595028229692065970.85780914429-57.7377967981293186699.141416839323042.9834091117420651.015255549101587.888442714256309Taperedpoint loadModerateLongGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic616112.30862806344285
82Aluminum109.697668731531140.318016034756790242581.65276581012131121.037610977370853.7394676163611616203.24088097327-46.51206699841739186324.049130039842351.5334758743350435.0423544048152213.818059038320515RectangularuniformModerateMediumGoodHighShark Optimizer1732140.40738772801836
83Aluminum92.510105192104760.331381245831341651632.2891527791583931.89655896499685.6060431401222718867.816225294133-59.74363383837469156542.48226010623853.5286645787907666.386351873200488.129975182447827Taperedpoint loadHighShortGoodHighShark Optimizer67787.73729944008977
84Titanium119.948724308862150.33390478774770862304.076833176831288.829654264737577.6007895112659215604.603059646399-43.85067458113683184574.928555297673754.7104140745369954.919311643465018.098797320047872TapereddistributedLowMediumGoodMediumShark Optimizer1391108.13528150327238
85Carbon Fiber56.686338381289140.320365809867556643093.3809843008311164.148063324763464.4219651671054419367.912280099918-46.38144919864643161609.340126289782654.6876747347762669.9633033354560614.107125159585612Cylindricalpoint loadLowShortPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic637145.4953148704685
86Titanium136.024423350055770.31997646701476151654.09933914672731466.86157389074892.4749603678906519004.393704124144-42.43799816750993139824.250598805553839.8243006017318745.0444552448584267.982842640112154RectangularuniformLowShortExcellentLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1610128.33100661294037
87Aluminum67.174968792241930.34326863554865034313.8920148252851442.388922134702959.43943794270910512547.280586836852-56.70300091882989122613.553879467862646.3375539900596948.1382940669169414.263387219328788Taperedpoint loadLowMediumPoorMediumShark Optimizer103398.94293905157
88Titanium82.878178013664980.33649862737859433316.797728932426332.33811828867884.7579800897439116535.54795771488-40.580372581811375104663.961786788963952.64009109603484462.9849832983157269.40585206861043TapereddistributedLowLongGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic919110.05412004922044
89Carbon Fiber145.28993702004970.30082973408925272589.8562861471873728.922194862857667.2355536290715716770.01891939393-56.28908635999404129616.193657292742732.7471103521401831.127470540975958.523971537937605Cylindricalpoint loadLowMediumExcellentLowChaotic Quantum Genetic926122.07972737777696
90Titanium76.914188307444590.338266090745332373963.0813739323544397.5841948049902678.573708309721615841.3062673969625-53.721357645780365180257.31831963132824.61840778486516645.4982194259595112.216320186765017TapereduniformHighMediumPoorLowShark Optimizer102254.70428535617845
91Titanium84.179351052625240.31218025786193193360.3709489052291318.815965698577265.968884536305515335.306645973911-47.97805863066143121387.670322589142826.3074006843522547.3367878354276647.5084923787657TapereddistributedLowMediumPoorMediumShark Optimizer57372.12455130423055
92Titanium179.835416249532360.30894273412610533416.5371445981073886.730816743871796.5936004352886218382.662411409477-48.845825048941734193147.057755918943445.9900305979195661.534201643241966.367703466391232CylindricaluniformHighMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1499127.21410070781467
93Aluminum162.6254959207120.343799088823731453551.8999388343941017.173763229841180.0048064219989810712.328185207765-48.0877281371544128374.044578311353857.6258037303111532.3054352066252614.273024190599045TapereduniformLowMediumExcellentLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1014141.90362306016485
94Carbon Fiber93.561375578526270.31634870318516674222.337339056994514.439564218278554.4397635853114311032.831741271959-41.884592228717985102086.062517260263253.36549259032512563.84466940148105610.755981578628298Rectangularpoint loadLowShortGoodMediumShark Optimizer1189120.31741367105886
95Titanium125.943953308179270.32599284330635922652.4227651285696575.194017582765479.108724605590037906.255859700976-51.43582154312202146497.770213282962734.09063377063514450.123243924656457.3928860970612265RectangulardistributedModerateShortPoorLowShark Optimizer1824113.22197585726792
96Titanium163.122949287756280.301261099705783242170.8433544605896909.261572839355264.414114348925956197.414138580061-49.2075455346522128914.256486131473230.2913671739881232.2117198273910512.118967907711234RectangularuniformModerateMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic135092.44591253858923
97Carbon Fiber124.076651225450020.328935810209391553999.5069650745954684.185864330232780.2707435333908415217.69602083406-46.71645249540837186377.75910581992152.6768888146513967.607700617781268.150328014686327TapereddistributedLowShortPoorHighShark Optimizer1365124.71678851700949
98Aluminum57.262145312864420.333134057846619764106.8894617291435403.695180414110558.74787224402163615493.47937763715-42.207651651908385115400.704197319433135.01974360155925662.6190521495783948.951652323766794TapereduniformLowShortPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic1811114.77977201388268
99Carbon Fiber179.8067900852970.314497259824274343673.83322856607451262.145634748091274.3197978679842210447.365730917183-50.1853252905379191436.58608636012446.8492320132861847.2242383866745413.331945677199382Cylindricalpoint loadLowMediumPoorLowShark Optimizer640106.15181505077253
100Titanium147.768776949116950.313685619943696543738.6460012436731034.67958903752287.381047437100428957.27656659461-50.694209202406846166086.752400338622521.375683535301969.4418938474457513.520506833772721CylindricaldistributedHighMediumPoorLowShark Optimizer1689106.04616787902143
101Aluminum52.1748838983086150.30534554826792952963.24785667280141260.423130689955882.64137896489067744.957008410021-58.762015592894045147178.033763339953327.12662848410721539.408046487747866.251924591518111Taperedpoint loadHighLongExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1965134.68943585110935
102Titanium184.438933242739580.34272474001354623081.61143200858171012.411428344290479.8558703661386517552.14089531356-43.21395269339199173357.294945329782423.83324561746139458.6189246750266211.710335336488098Taperedpoint loadLowLongPoorLowShark Optimizer1435148.7771228636147
103Titanium135.638362847042150.33800054783875571600.1814750305803782.251041363774491.028123435701625654.629158427554-46.11129129115784130299.804194756333740.16655934820746451.83803873946196510.84089152020642CylindricaldistributedModerateMediumPoorMediumShark Optimizer846139.97693553342418
104Carbon Fiber76.799544851323030.33502775454289162450.18220391890741386.992969961818782.5433697044488814703.58215175283-56.31346256463422140125.70899556633027.234045060377248.9204228790435857.789585518853858CylindricaluniformLowShortPoorLowShark Optimizer190792.43929081236843
105Aluminum60.484449471074330.335043097688399462183.992958975346782.546788231410759.858784414484757301.053983427482-53.88347973151224126736.587025520572454.6751761718724468.507121849209926.0708501885579915RectangulardistributedModerateMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1721108.49183953081575
106Carbon Fiber90.491543436048960.332220960258089842208.6714016493424413.891406182441199.3937630850139612125.377621674106-44.539279122247294115139.122075270223839.0863864764570257.897550351314312.206436604463606CylindricaldistributedHighMediumPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic52477.1825197184895
107Titanium91.552827623723120.315193262390746461529.522483135766636.381142536654954.8052168144414656550.204949242153-58.31718693262403184320.133054221632347.2194968163010853.4710499859300612.949744147157727RectangulardistributedModerateLongGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic740144.65566043534244
108Aluminum85.99026869128480.34797151890503393964.347313215337645.223210847161292.747702714437217429.68411424043-49.630410373214644139443.12199994633752.54279008279933566.6574673957540514.775731161383984CylindricaluniformModerateLongPoorLowShark Optimizer633131.80829509282373
109Carbon Fiber61.8512081600317960.315000712039217873714.0441049746532534.130075882719795.358217774865445376.9094436591495-43.67594480135925120686.649213331643550.2489081046966348.7811516742333146.738799006066547CylindricaldistributedModerateShortGoodMediumShark Optimizer139457.76785847832193
110Aluminum89.981763089286690.326938607234535442476.648622188361773.981156049680575.975515874323888513.151285149126-41.97345649364107195790.869910827873352.15549986893192647.5012135360342813.533282271009968CylindricaluniformModerateLongGoodMediumShark Optimizer1926142.0687875584573
111Titanium114.587920683070950.347179887299285953548.066634951153472.2681804491953760.82541358215540612397.296734391202-44.96809602863618109252.975388189883535.25280665231199649.524098763575666.277228607325734CylindricaluniformHighMediumExcellentMediumShark Optimizer1979141.38383190273504
112Carbon Fiber133.553861297798450.323348334858645563610.7854629797057535.710034447889792.021169030330955813.421316815419-49.03787996966923109574.011247776143848.0679123283308636.8345601331805111.127192618083626Rectangularpoint loadModerateShortGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1449125.03889027541749
113Titanium66.479477439578620.342749862745846463846.3888902281137538.45568048800388.484116598320877811.667803370031-48.7320001610111155470.411333332423432.0912256691772944.35676407772423610.573351661330681TapereddistributedLowLongPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic170886.59310520121974
114Aluminum77.861745159769370.315388703138707043896.04622227536631163.10879350801471.0466637514025818302.015784343395-57.78311731623569150027.951228636383232.04026470899404450.4092466146305265.260121543019829RectangularuniformModerateLongExcellentHighShark Optimizer81098.60631343370214
115Aluminum112.27615616441970.318008144271604842411.1353541531134467.480041881683488.4926392132208315107.823364204856-53.9863382600782175355.212502066572726.47667005525945839.5355294779198456.470289674258533RectangulardistributedLowMediumExcellentMediumShark Optimizer107667.4946347328466
116Aluminum187.64446692196420.33142882146294052791.01837352989151414.690290560856584.6625947174906811895.22624081189-56.49351242659862151452.580121541543143.6126753111100836.9196240578407812.305670374205134CylindricaldistributedLowMediumPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic1356112.8758049224953
117Titanium154.133281431342430.331111312210191632368.758026252045923.71972857215567.5749924329065816940.13352251224-41.05446756842128134482.638588022323449.5262846365648339.0219320785586913.239061626007185TapereddistributedModerateShortPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic150290.24037707766176
118Titanium89.773614084496090.3324326211307943367.89611655292261435.402668106254275.2181710996418615295.496048689403-57.47851364286974151666.249132471333031.81479120778313469.821455325490339.523130203191599Rectangularpoint loadLowShortGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic140276.87656310879599
119Titanium197.693071844066650.348478702268761651570.685866530031447.341294771460372.658089086301417361.399115659715-48.06052289673833141548.57354834233640.5383271032090639.4735207023392413.26296515992648Rectangularpoint loadLowMediumGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic134883.4801248818049
120Titanium87.513860463819670.343239171078566661777.36197977347661129.811613553939466.9120929324330419384.641940425056-42.17199580752094138340.75257795433635.40076771269010460.682665140966445.123799088300558CylindricaluniformLowLongExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic182186.73927123073273
121Aluminum174.538680257382960.3090290960889931643.5731187737154935.308264477346358.56419763618540511611.316386978557-44.2779567902355189740.606952584763143.54231076271831660.6996820247538559.895327791074955CylindricaldistributedLowShortGoodHighShark Optimizer1518124.96019751647364
122Titanium134.698884926740670.34317043403497573309.188097628775284.2164552388871466.056711494853649611.413062072319-57.950069664464536177773.24695504843232.8450079275457130.438542979186147.940841423962398CylindricaldistributedModerateLongExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic594111.85652966282001
123Carbon Fiber105.160664059205490.327720511463887863305.2576172329027268.3713312295946650.4245676710693410441.975487963136-46.75652902792134103581.232609834272625.3905246148865137.816779944998896.0937220031791615RectangulardistributedModerateMediumPoorHighShark Optimizer121884.15458419080369
124Aluminum97.137443389261560.339590998068804552255.456180250895553.353843207568452.237988569619117760.888281471534-42.99502435634451147666.859319947753041.1906185478182451.6479238181182614.21017510417067Cylindricalpoint loadLowLongPoorMediumShark Optimizer1178136.4119098818287
125Titanium192.65956866064060.33783709649510133475.1566421289217689.345675261864493.742808346966855147.811439144733-43.11403607341548152409.22630327843527.13927159160462258.045103766788717.743057042050042Cylindricalpoint loadHighMediumGoodHighShark Optimizer1971123.02089026723817
126Carbon Fiber196.685523306758850.31128545304179882104.6775781740321349.389457710911560.8850918246630319749.57673470555-41.159506382576694152536.96911553633358.50642428306982664.42857355155536.522153852040402TapereduniformLowLongPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic136166.391583625597
127Aluminum183.89061671806150.307680252502475942792.9898542986843432.015176090789364.3518862995041912449.436906372677-50.047748024349914154025.398742715652542.2767584618708160.3884319697627355.978819853403826Cylindricalpoint loadModerateShortPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1951114.86525085726123
128Aluminum75.026298626386260.3034939068730943712.984129576242483.748993522657173.5066404684706413766.919044327262-56.578325577555596183421.974725041953453.3437153213488131.3661598331386111.065663369285133TapereddistributedLowMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic94193.87709462046075
129Aluminum148.175070468706420.303433478591793764144.1534229696335889.59168271102296.172297434925929651.934666546655-42.79316945644997138332.172401946423148.0812319366510447.2952644991554113.135265800208934Taperedpoint loadModerateMediumExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic101297.52940579142154
130Carbon Fiber54.472721342036940.317755271550647643460.83221436981151036.810104788284283.0644749263671514440.62966348379-45.08295472893391167130.182157414972452.1220622513753153.6420973393818114.835461010921428RectangularuniformModerateShortGoodLowShark Optimizer102998.48692606574215
131Aluminum184.269983228603760.329692374372342333985.2314463717621206.187001715614886.5771803726496810894.644347613863-47.022903257793324155604.472762257042128.62955274995212659.57839437390545414.271975743658572Cylindricalpoint loadHighShortPoorLowShark Optimizer1239122.80685546103992
132Carbon Fiber139.020434279252730.32500811295165414291.9279114301521130.59967741374868.504575702048025645.495309064314-48.00680390378453165496.355070620783122.15973103381625757.57000053474775.350588884653103RectangularuniformHighLongGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic916122.16155333019158
133Titanium121.238890606853430.32335845139768193048.947946973595490.785374101125582.9380228926079612672.684476010534-55.43245509249938181295.120311008133641.5620708371620437.95253584673809411.808620138399139Rectangularpoint loadLowMediumExcellentMediumShark Optimizer149052.00685457980736
134Carbon Fiber103.747186222768330.315582853471575941835.9898025286757850.269837804826790.6970166301385918223.966410806264-40.414440592247686120916.404440776172334.688003736498963.01935887792597.244540051765682Rectangularpoint loadHighShortExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic82975.19060715180943
135Carbon Fiber192.591857930825540.333292945628101632645.173561643849511.52254746940456.69324770172145417944.279026943692-42.211968491519755193557.61079083642134.65737634799100461.201795472708537.899245459553135TapereduniformModerateShortGoodLowShark Optimizer1419118.47300008219133
136Carbon Fiber53.174768074038470.3196326386914022002.345274060352535.490151307714391.0912214811210419286.592328659746-59.66907516208308150487.076234447422324.25770088860335665.5209479214011913.676073300570717TapereddistributedLowLongGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic798130.21788948829868
137Carbon Fiber109.42216127423470.3216064427362652046.8231193278575705.930986432506364.092184139652395455.518387373402-47.4582094452839173146.817117103963848.5348353280983557.6707123874396511.27161216136317Taperedpoint loadLowMediumPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic868147.3923714934731
138Carbon Fiber105.000831873855840.3387452852803194406.6001096976711309.348326856648393.1613500376662713484.513327977136-59.974258571539366149388.188784929172639.8101889615146766.2599126624832211.462097690084299CylindricaluniformLowShortExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1085116.47401671538692
139Carbon Fiber139.129986473716030.3335782229455543872.93319182413821130.524988363043359.9652290479839115058.745505322488-40.781461829059864164561.105362445232130.31169614910038566.8517152148087312.576601361707985Cylindricalpoint loadHighShortGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic642108.18021051868077
140Titanium178.342926505839440.32858256889286684041.218324251428747.429268929409161.0441931430894515747.358358155669-59.619443238050074186124.719657723332043.9938835898867861.524323632928978.986222935906731Cylindricalpoint loadLowShortGoodLowShark Optimizer148892.13461998585927
141Carbon Fiber89.064881648567730.320062187676728062265.009788081885400.5340180725707589.2517933750900919360.45310237301-52.24926922162031136357.071503516023531.55560286926933255.458237762817912.179902476548945TapereddistributedModerateMediumGoodLowShark Optimizer159361.39788768823497
142Aluminum114.084550865219780.328586067780148762579.6187002416881096.236601813580850.7574420392082415770.722855352524-46.777237406433414162497.422229983962137.2600796290276958.787843554575588.494933543287914Cylindricalpoint loadModerateLongGoodHighShark Optimizer123391.93645735693049
143Carbon Fiber119.683002072238350.318724159976625843433.15457822325971371.888653786750979.769756049445366967.806137314897-55.096142053456326112462.272002572543122.9703833958768556.5842403155612466.375768310642897CylindricaluniformModerateLongExcellentLowShark Optimizer1423148.97420523569332
144Carbon Fiber132.99399495399040.344796390690797763476.4041108633046923.240821741828567.8556984985426718175.71287544536-46.65734817258223157846.967521883343146.3274273052177167.244692023518310.686985080167831CylindricaldistributedLowShortExcellentLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1802122.90192889070134
145Carbon Fiber60.625433506607320.315989886054336872390.4868047250041056.002799991751597.2803784725522319538.86506732287-43.711810468025206173937.424212659192438.4099507467558353.189935489958668.732877172504182TapereduniformModerateLongGoodHighShark Optimizer932131.91397502133577
146Titanium69.26884543990150.33520421869072774408.555860765388423.7933346901916785.960185348483586535.025753933452-51.49850969731044182419.43025947762157.0208717243710669.6907210263861312.524962426554502Taperedpoint loadHighShortPoorMediumShark Optimizer94956.536142251083575
147Titanium175.73839439824630.34975765070722711772.6252700272731450.270662693144568.0748641212945115654.748781061939-47.82957670374314103193.682790422562750.34396939652679533.19553752834383414.445669216834713TapereddistributedLowMediumGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic177596.96868840261266
148Aluminum92.173690178941060.322312196498486363547.270666909043346.7200600627275564.8681764601719447.543984281649-49.20214419374315128141.723806045272647.303715067176563.331957239892847.060983369885894Cylindricalpoint loadHighLongGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1537141.12887351646413
149Aluminum194.728766080439160.34982606315539114387.8031132906211228.093958135853462.682291127498819416.925001688753-48.48670140557605141100.429426969933148.78292342023253553.35782039032713411.49624403543298RectangulardistributedLowShortPoorHighShark Optimizer1971116.59133508826464
150Carbon Fiber166.56052351686010.332986036789339253292.0130106779766490.6455806483388660.728701118587317476.652857763972-47.519886799846894151279.477812594332632.8402955681481747.3527152404031857.615954699090288Cylindricalpoint loadModerateMediumGoodHighShark Optimizer1959141.50475362786983
151Carbon Fiber136.404838564922440.330290493203890372073.105157809348517.204215428920294.0523444112023416722.14045369842-44.43309736464278129883.170286280672527.74922387191653436.135151568849175.137279504616382Taperedpoint loadLowShortPoorHighShark Optimizer1228106.17100002733649
152Aluminum199.834683756645520.32019722631542913600.6859324170505551.442263203362890.219230736661885548.178019648359-47.38878647519978133278.96468667583927.01466000713329460.86665978977515610.560645886031729CylindricaluniformLowMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1633141.72752839006483
153Titanium63.3466145796428750.303069115463042362.88077542114341415.920354505277180.581644477224717351.474946353977-40.12230196353694127459.856866273392440.9846716794458338.0504283471558447.273395981229688RectangularuniformHighMediumExcellentMediumShark Optimizer709146.03254076967374
154Aluminum99.038146142075730.323420990986435342375.1714757871277820.754828763347772.903203986321475932.701076781486-54.6511846056833111264.171082809043848.0237009873047557.0041106476794712.520428253767896RectangulardistributedHighMediumPoorHighShark Optimizer149370.17661097124184
155Titanium75.406875405404950.33156918607833432497.8342587290663957.127926685389888.7046309617049417441.343051357162-51.20483888905378163243.33484764232153.41427369091437.682689114812296.887629248729828RectangulardistributedModerateShortGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic1457125.32675334813422
156Aluminum68.76469149460480.307776584914713553897.7519265548394609.999060789345355.796523999710576645.951986020225-48.53260671660293164627.09293742133257.637142148669141.1843330560351711.440008392983039RectangularuniformModerateLongGoodLowShark Optimizer738121.9161392642731
157Aluminum166.847377202369980.32833921994231624304.190176824549620.498021482742498.2742327922936216250.081921951974-40.81208789865232149185.17094263673525.76848300874214848.061389690342685.228257496224748CylindricaldistributedHighShortGoodLowShark Optimizer1217125.02294232646437
158Aluminum120.098371127256170.344615685259586633213.67065430371081175.626992812386880.420297144414414083.385127608668-54.26931548662968131238.06566049023321.57867696116013836.8012091857555810.841519321370292RectangularuniformModerateMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic83164.45477053451731
159Aluminum56.697099450591870.31574073035028293826.4104862846931080.925905109061758.835894121436276590.089848760536-41.41535206449319187033.308652028272343.9112212717081351.115710411222417.989444813261352TapereduniformModerateLongGoodLowShark Optimizer90163.51697588851752
160Aluminum156.821383098818760.31946072613292554085.234923360307627.93208314241581.560179629436496001.6215767873855-41.11837071458906164988.115055869682545.9821312451923360.3829200852692910.809049344061492Taperedpoint loadHighLongGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic696109.09169970740332
161Carbon Fiber187.112711475065740.327346951421712162643.4174143563941308.186369051673490.7959481758989118118.679212605603-42.69021349117605170333.40834420963652.8600118687969941.9075223518117311.133548285596133Cylindricalpoint loadHighShortExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic970104.04109691705183
162Titanium71.908953452098830.307314566733716932162.8354070282476733.100441136108978.2873488097130119543.093051009295-40.260691173904554162301.128338832822025.44204587305499433.64006287068037414.621281977080816Cylindricalpoint loadModerateShortPoorLowShark Optimizer1613116.92311497595226
163Aluminum126.242441260278710.32888025046314414171.673435526482980.47823033544550.108445008581146793.918802491668-40.409615991806774147705.585528539263430.9136796775316763.5771446776653110.107418686608852RectangularuniformLowMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic96788.67737684798796
164Aluminum132.768099713997860.321897805821616763417.14160583138289.573733023648783.5672264232674114121.649937067752-56.12069347854465191521.678297823442448.3467103726038464.102862532736577.508791361437304TapereduniformModerateShortExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic187759.83994986148069
165Carbon Fiber87.273374180297980.30586190783822974495.7590880951271276.691364775005262.4777241766452466093.353110750253-47.909534456511075172851.744634507342449.35474419418696432.06867411167111.7714425156925CylindricaldistributedHighLongGoodLowShark Optimizer1101112.9440876077484
166Titanium116.94146199995630.339336573891001142423.071316464411343.640736812852891.0400923691000411240.295163927125-49.4982234096901180430.247250628052438.6973224611713830.6689719937066068.25551629521799Cylindricalpoint loadModerateLongExcellentLowShark Optimizer106788.93385095457998
167Aluminum199.68743034981910.30471977047197324424.727677117145558.64499915954895.580796685430447914.392919918006-59.17744253906887135754.782163457423745.5125658873413734.41919605950092611.230571539488661Cylindricalpoint loadModerateShortExcellentHighShark Optimizer924132.38295848454538
168Carbon Fiber75.514849456599930.334058575669205943363.14871207866871194.049346158604756.3307418694160946045.464723982278-53.59800941435614147713.747959573962434.60368527974435466.92635749442358.986823689904723CylindricaldistributedModerateMediumExcellentLowShark Optimizer188182.44187083874371
169Aluminum94.565560892030330.324714895725688571584.5843655427811331.8278527657180359.226384256323256882.740038603013-50.04815261162904187062.108940177833721.85563874119320745.0890748994388910.654477149270479CylindricaldistributedLowShortExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic660142.44977118998773
170Titanium67.561579988541030.307837955275935551836.821865576465877.576659602390956.60668205011426903.689512086867-53.7507415039341158602.448781139282426.61291820595096565.0463568073608512.977760179877997TapereduniformModerateLongPoorHighShark Optimizer120370.64000738974406
171Titanium125.079385766154930.321891478860416642782.8714251932015718.967085166070866.6510151410272915294.060891879028-51.23347730450811144137.305345341852642.70009782060263655.9806029222307914.705272243484217CylindricaluniformModerateMediumGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic72562.27031892039555
172Titanium171.801221643606680.33314307074044522251.918018777694514.499974514983799.6046679955458411283.724755384825-56.66569701916052154999.7553199853830.5795333370432867.7299424283793612.229155159854734CylindricaluniformModerateShortPoorMediumShark Optimizer1032134.07035448382464
173Carbon Fiber138.967999139881950.340497353138480342426.01338036374641118.38288228001592.5794916114475410483.325884279644-40.03928514984504127953.532120843742346.95953544746128549.8486254914152710.171385333543206Taperedpoint loadModerateMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic111551.89795087302753
174Titanium170.824490167262240.319429751703200263193.2421121115203721.198878718192979.8181730467373716097.863768073987-50.58823880556335184786.236050193324.56982353481828759.820522566294678.35684247123519TapereddistributedHighLongExcellentLowShark Optimizer1428119.59362289246151
175Titanium93.727923022243570.33961160476498383275.5856375930666412.6990170685113560.2607306423229414552.069800588883-43.26346955265798182321.98848710713652.0532105848951847.35234734264534510.791958622189856Taperedpoint loadModerateMediumExcellentMediumShark Optimizer620132.8946773365208
176Titanium128.3385916068340.3183902045376934156.482730017622733.483557935574492.021805813186319935.24077476948-56.850923338378564192002.1431459623845.8901879966682966.4635922132603114.152896210103163CylindricaluniformLowLongGoodHighShark Optimizer1148132.33449945744422
177Aluminum73.80901495659660.34081774308262132448.57691288687241396.015277107788564.956952576970556579.9292426561415-59.621153861919844158525.73668868482523.99723446641892747.12495923821606414.003469289536568RectangularuniformLowShortExcellentHighShark Optimizer626139.9244882646708
178Titanium73.329304658716810.342727454018805832534.934963035566490.323106456614850.753938126274395778.830183082483-50.97413969615735194582.213020452883755.06041644599153542.870588335755076.5783400656322275TapereddistributedModerateLongGoodHighShark Optimizer105664.88532297441647
179Titanium180.096201330450380.32438646786219222369.803768005643889.392942938964954.0398706686687813138.41567489173-52.05198449209837103293.434515243853238.8119400735133732.0699893992604866.648687829011585CylindricaldistributedLowMediumPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic71268.51025671837998
180Titanium101.079484810192350.339603137882973141889.85790517546251124.298830645350362.8534997818906312309.01725714908-45.96427553301792105879.522013635843925.7206443324193449.417695844815035.5465256548168504Cylindricalpoint loadHighMediumGoodHighShark Optimizer1283137.07259263296592
181Titanium109.192771929556730.327945494132665273187.2397495107853293.6502123989651586.966319411139113603.171726785527-45.672039740679665128067.735785069422523.56743904549411554.14881348905202413.120443138632027CylindricaldistributedLowLongPoorHighShark Optimizer523113.42455169039488
182Carbon Fiber152.66960235043660.329528978731528752708.4365867001634737.801514479056389.8994048656096517775.09829661627-47.309929390925745141917.395044879933158.058207647741433.7007091439885213.023187220065957RectangulardistributedHighMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic91458.620883204954865
183Carbon Fiber112.008819591335450.318658865498791242755.436104319301827.403430169426489.7493042255832214838.05760832567-45.552019841846985112338.636439950163353.9367512627410542.1376207905266549.703516423209647CylindricaluniformLowMediumPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic119792.89287075409526
184Carbon Fiber60.707890092819950.315677970983010373374.33295924338651333.345886540505364.9653607942392513371.680365898603-49.542903560932444132120.002675187863855.6404157652753861.1113974195456714.891479885329671CylindricaluniformHighLongPoorHighShark Optimizer105652.03076503170191
185Carbon Fiber152.780951826412380.34357107791829593245.7268453799197330.606354001654183.9813796497371617329.41791403921-48.83775942445844167410.033307418583954.504418957379931.2833801476034912.213018309392393RectangulardistributedLowMediumPoorHighShark Optimizer54885.3271833848091
186Titanium71.823786040021120.32294634230871634262.4569636484375751.334694843776974.094681835408086359.634529770067-52.93897848034652113917.696909904483926.35510076018661636.623709114188385.779340000642436Rectangularpoint loadModerateShortExcellentHighShark Optimizer89279.46087045377946
187Titanium112.887458597763030.33800309893245352353.831236769237609.659857868181587.8447015157420617566.83131929546-56.98103002033637190363.4845312813322.16219167936599659.2799717676381213.54248522244884CylindricaluniformLowLongGoodHighShark Optimizer1212124.75508064914825
188Carbon Fiber67.782197341868540.332654221452853062725.3605330716911205.320407206138566.8419896826543610805.422987986924-52.72093138532442187830.110619320362444.9652385788796868.6894450056619712.849360176457019CylindricaldistributedHighLongGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic175459.38920611494613
189Aluminum199.786062736741430.3078653672386714304.972831494888564.598580633503754.573309609258415720.149500251373-58.189778883064335132944.425554128922041.8794421533377668.824100158276998.7020863196409Rectangularpoint loadModerateLongExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic167456.20041624840617
190Titanium99.91591216947450.32156794733160013104.85048605476781404.200952825204799.5349260996533916797.347420211536-58.58934051995491109472.155552365133443.119646299067350.65083642148566411.05158755097041Rectangularpoint loadLowShortExcellentMediumShark Optimizer156379.19727407478022
191Aluminum99.850724060419250.336943466223346263488.91154579163731081.296735182781559.554456345924095113.454695968275-58.713687019179254186970.556632270772224.9499135224873443.0504414301241959.710147732066435TapereddistributedLowLongExcellentHighShark Optimizer1013100.21775025214265
192Titanium133.459666738269450.327533189330129044116.3768207747931428.462714931019786.3628514985805810185.161725647138-41.74214783029139199838.637346699433437.38048659352665535.38011065837079610.303594291097014CylindricaldistributedModerateMediumPoorMediumShark Optimizer739105.61200759744418
193Titanium126.500169015278330.34253300241072493674.7584963395907664.995779254554284.422305766828069402.140775464159-53.64645590379666187629.04725392542030.06663399636549657.7981886074197469.566723001663053RectangulardistributedHighShortExcellentMediumShark Optimizer183952.97313133525133
194Carbon Fiber158.202496992786730.322606350618288743752.2161815070735279.4836712311220676.336194287270378881.060893684102-58.55166580633603129150.503433726032754.79630152990187562.7488103299860213.418383768935735TapereduniformLowShortGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1825144.4092085062881
195Titanium168.186286625635430.32303923001403244118.84046314861551196.78706536841452.1970716395756758486.47982359324-49.61997957460107146707.42149530513132.520319938088961.1029137128568412.014884030961241TapereduniformModerateShortGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic896131.7161089292363
196Carbon Fiber93.477351720746470.32768196761447982461.4502324587656893.160828401001888.673224849978686318.7151113607615-45.27239417126991166276.466748185572859.70047073193608644.3526817785055411.628575506756757Taperedpoint loadLowLongExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1409113.61113754907214
197Titanium78.747672082148910.33931601646352872057.2710092399061099.907385725883280.9241471370478710019.07631869839-54.69440571537877196017.240960544273949.97152252370905542.4776965522085213.832703481352116TapereddistributedHighLongGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic67275.75295895588889
198Aluminum137.31566646473440.31673038310726942273.51898115326764.442471871311574.5518157201404511358.504149523967-46.34248615756951186888.27860830533424.33281373491264866.4648976600850414.524090817490867RectangulardistributedLowLongPoorLowShark Optimizer1601131.29518574000878
199Carbon Fiber130.482089715110930.338760120647991942768.28419827616841419.699008733050369.4259881322102619416.25121338723-58.53002632646023157355.111696213543924.7893255230238448.408909899911.793058438855784RectangularuniformModerateShortPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1221134.3131854824422
200Titanium63.3249628726871950.30808690920585253061.478556553598871.287792232385571.063685164854798113.543617345882-50.274422033708845140441.77453847452051.4757522631569531.21110217797516712.559639350984689Rectangularpoint loadModerateLongExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic699135.73738575527426
201Titanium123.535657218621580.30194547736716412092.86536204744241071.55135090928897.667637762986359769.9545023014-57.71260017205171197133.84447646022726.60190763991267550.8313512473838810.083783780990393Taperedpoint loadHighMediumExcellentLowShark Optimizer895149.83364146455503
202Carbon Fiber109.44901545478120.34933044504783363615.67790261837441162.384948723567784.0972908620385814541.30925567411-48.164918890181845138151.102515207723442.5284890355389457.382843620951268.237433673721114Cylindricalpoint loadModerateMediumGoodMediumShark Optimizer61579.10062304982083
203Titanium187.283034178584020.32680884800069972480.3234434401056701.822340454341978.635750995234846921.19655520528-40.97457228204692151900.343891427683331.15793087592836542.7209479552392812.599270883937432CylindricaldistributedLowLongGoodMediumShark Optimizer161072.13513294682767
204Carbon Fiber117.94923934948340.308900087190636053543.270095672942711.492678511239160.4664629901342758052.351570900372-58.41390438974412179659.300998745433830.45843610197062335.140329037735695.17665603182364RectangularuniformHighMediumPoorHighShark Optimizer1961132.48423534114286
205Titanium161.32991325267020.32996915051315161914.48338361071751124.950183135940370.7437778142891718759.32532046469-43.09644160936145169385.619507499772825.77854697259195465.3335644695616814.8800238827295Rectangularpoint loadLowMediumGoodMediumShark Optimizer1179141.4768127000948
206Carbon Fiber131.537226963937850.32101775782870894351.720576933076830.952287437155252.4821538244827311997.669731326761-44.70364888805722160890.993384291532621.70353438918475330.9297049589380047.957677732156462CylindricaluniformLowShortGoodHighShark Optimizer1095132.57037458431398
207Titanium115.54218364423940.323899075839982452842.3475771895073860.837683282062793.806440427120589151.577712295943-48.36929942011754174367.474355089072249.0412666429955565.0105188061704711.029100023969796RectangularuniformHighShortGoodMediumShark Optimizer1857148.94514534036836
208Carbon Fiber107.377478919793180.305791214109879143883.98440935154031424.66375527744574.8039335069196811959.579313290447-41.27448348614631139227.466340580782122.2042785905806845.3482897151454810.671933220076628Rectangularpoint loadHighMediumExcellentHighShark Optimizer946148.57945163008623
209Carbon Fiber144.793555697515560.304014401971990873352.744181713453510.191444157400882.226991897139914253.075194501742-45.18778171701921143006.459030881323639.3621995324466666.268978633500958.566996455448294RectangulardistributedModerateMediumExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic1305100.87720026479181
210Titanium84.530874736848030.31621608637215833534.2925631675453374.1716383226705651.6895035989657157543.510330141304-52.02872614226409180752.534487970382421.360891561093630.37835308597305710.34132843272321CylindricaluniformHighLongGoodMediumShark Optimizer1133117.16748745373539
211Carbon Fiber168.657289864665070.333003083992345743444.14208633670021064.47510143868288.7206972752077815797.595304615263-56.16920982151109106122.186229001163929.1766226881893935.9171947528842212.912029831038916Rectangularpoint loadLowMediumPoorLowShark Optimizer1932103.06570831206002
212Titanium183.5011136341110.34257863030287831779.977470346558591.058836871574463.8184562866668915416.903081321543-49.057924891994816126681.355981850973128.78874700350107241.1498485915688269.053157559123933TapereddistributedModerateMediumPoorLowShark Optimizer1828129.26829528750548
213Aluminum161.174485306360050.32313939006376633963.8079137082327811.320538055899362.8729606822110719126.645016357095-50.925493922973395190515.406221722432848.26691771209810669.3844989879681611.113015503806395RectangulardistributedHighMediumExcellentMediumShark Optimizer914142.24981809497183
214Carbon Fiber58.0312668330124740.304004456701950252017.2896486078218978.225362503675164.273027682899619088.780933865164-57.798662948257224143405.540172493582428.0150576687892558.1079066017927913.596178637277045Taperedpoint loadHighShortPoorLowShark Optimizer193179.87429925535136
215Titanium136.375702972126760.333342052236891550.048780843938559.78364935976291.409581153450337915.29748861066-47.457077299388146146187.35480082533620.62411277886455739.5610223518426956.343586350155961RectangularuniformModerateLongPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic113897.73123836389028
216Carbon Fiber152.734051905778240.309260243163658742761.11311430903331333.47635656721269.688152813904725520.245690458759-57.58023072754013101602.679804361133350.67843673088917568.284552662344057.558440556547277TapereduniformModerateMediumExcellentLowShark Optimizer1200110.09101922559063
217Carbon Fiber57.651812324059350.33963110051402932084.8499154694873796.304090702985452.81528755406018413338.838661242955-55.709090315430224117838.793860391133045.9743767383767235.73986656360169413.714408959552953CylindricaldistributedModerateLongPoorHighShark Optimizer1500145.43479233206568
218Aluminum138.009364623118640.340085599901559732180.076257600897412.828385830165186.6737211447180918081.527465381667-51.36536544876153116965.268404376232437.2217277119890332.05614471035223512.96176874333899TapereddistributedModerateMediumExcellentHighShark Optimizer1320141.9082454648015
219Titanium196.845944761262840.308508456678447732175.3043891890643521.808451323716797.619493499879139391.424635768917-44.53569017196954111947.85960104322329.7479663804000334.026392783135119.337394759048873TapereddistributedLowMediumPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic102890.02667642409997
220Carbon Fiber125.009819453477180.32401825305882672232.72469634214171275.719581137113474.3549005846082616228.05210583642-52.26426132990494139790.16018273282926.4834728908847743.637056722868637.567715406697869TapereddistributedHighShortExcellentLowShark Optimizer100553.295603308285756
221Aluminum125.47081652723720.314097414584998073142.899157908142484.082377006845692.630916165593486712.079144696568-47.57403797580669173312.728428135222328.58848761630852742.351956721913386.269652526124117CylindricaluniformLowMediumPoorLowShark Optimizer187764.63359850697437
222Titanium187.382528389933550.312785774043731764154.0047649080571279.030152828318769.782222040738138369.025762996407-45.56440913091964124798.410868241683439.2140702599218353.298589062885349.957279404793724RectangulardistributedHighShortPoorHighShark Optimizer78754.69873674920136
223Aluminum198.975730820464260.316118051523767434249.546997931168561.434704937358978.9815168606294112759.169213647192-49.63077723689678122600.181594260153942.6954307856221363.53212849200285.13882024963404RectangularuniformLowLongExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic780109.48976221438011
224Carbon Fiber67.33272141260770.313299923981703143980.7547502357481055.526629572756398.6452723974916519671.280386867606-40.575220575982776165555.16065100822844.6736868807705641.338317109667916.507958579841045CylindricaldistributedModerateMediumPoorLowShark Optimizer860129.59724070261154
225Titanium153.443391825963540.333283752378130574376.079652658282594.445659394330356.2799805627601719213.456966310776-51.60061157221861144812.757377870583253.3281993964612448.756721923375829.788017251789842TapereddistributedHighLongGoodHighShark Optimizer139658.694753247750796
226Carbon Fiber161.74495530000910.30232944248649611857.46608046303941089.28379717565452.883668790070449748.459592535786-50.329528080283026140712.493954194243628.0276559200611543.388529617742158.301754947348403Cylindricalpoint loadHighLongGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1921138.4107694682034
227Aluminum183.4490686798440.34743828416176923511.96305904093151037.04196963599570.9081643085262716558.04577283501-43.065584496641875103447.105458760473643.309966274176148.393978259110576.526074212954347Taperedpoint loadLowShortExcellentLowShark Optimizer1897110.43117133437039
228Aluminum84.341752980143740.329234960986393272937.631457719022747.887333786001182.067291452459710459.033005382134-58.861280769856197460.250652638443539.37199181531694655.9136981769496212.533248237095753Rectangularpoint loadHighLongGoodLowShark Optimizer184453.83283357820259
229Aluminum67.422425633330390.31982414803715654034.4540017486343865.845432119012289.8978260044033318327.72732919913-45.960759413066256127743.95017959642446.6902893716587764.364735876013578.269387610657912Cylindricalpoint loadModerateLongGoodMediumShark Optimizer1292130.4977015541189
230Aluminum53.4287977425348760.307019779546305273880.92600949174631427.505344942069586.5833380531542519841.77115868535-40.78009536430089159551.21776480682436.3510148103397657.7118751920494313.537845454417953TapereddistributedLowLongGoodHighShark Optimizer76469.11169350391867
231Carbon Fiber57.0852390622429550.311102956089308552351.3419501807161120.55829868526258.76034604935987514645.49745718864-54.566123079950394167206.286034393943841.9239952883704838.1643377298427810.349883951908946RectangulardistributedLowMediumPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1897114.52518324912403
232Carbon Fiber168.196159393157270.32637708925506513792.81639601744471364.276074025519686.5451811953246916342.860787792799-52.85236979846153106835.903029893993832.2521476233888439.0835711357351710.03724920221303Cylindricalpoint loadLowShortExcellentLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1080127.31209225597671
233Carbon Fiber50.14751994179250.32243258357454882168.98590158964361493.054927364762591.9647132635498417054.683588562442-41.225334562671016150129.638206262032255.9043788183358959.602748544531286.3050341682685005TapereduniformHighShortGoodHighShark Optimizer88456.96457478298099
234Aluminum159.077301240382750.347993946654939163297.2093547244895282.135994580393169.7889422680549117758.767533921025-56.7120251199934111919.59327746713957.80594913302141443.5436971048009714.4217296994304Rectangularpoint loadModerateLongPoorMediumShark Optimizer149071.35566842173844
235Titanium128.348813457406270.33876256968345263134.1917049602225668.020269203024769.7928957730798516752.713305694906-48.92199507477562160168.289052751642653.0536878738149560.1601817815557812.076046186049634TapereduniformHighLongGoodHighShark Optimizer173090.34207811742473
236Aluminum129.41762547055610.32623900163059743549.57740622188615.302553757735379.0716902089465311849.012576972262-42.95362668552802163034.674945482053127.68337687430747764.085439085397166.2561395983859915Cylindricalpoint loadLowMediumGoodLowShark Optimizer128463.11740273130661
237Carbon Fiber60.8063372989612960.32302229604956913321.2724277481525801.943420677341590.7667730553497257.273913628722-40.52741253068015119170.990418700183037.461743326772653.4756965150263645.007289818643935TapereduniformHighShortGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1096141.90390813477325
238Carbon Fiber191.85428374943780.30371132486832761586.72722650858121313.930643774923578.2185215261889118824.23209280477-58.52091695519492122776.873651206263851.3601188076549348.2800896963048510.079738727492192Rectangularpoint loadLowMediumGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1053148.3250831379027
239Titanium159.142930079222340.326104408316990343163.516545861131921.015791198957678.888805065094613399.177494955497-43.7081038131101197546.095568945223558.7520280545548434.3572291353836613.546434072556297RectangulardistributedModerateMediumGoodLowShark Optimizer136580.38110095341474
240Aluminum95.507659531612590.30022578032822723158.62560195421341490.523537065188376.0179788216744617631.090753943892-52.76475754892414115894.112742215053849.16300642580823440.866344089859858.992884408791785TapereduniformModerateShortGoodMediumShark Optimizer110271.98895383216399
241Carbon Fiber177.082284460538970.33725492442061473393.5636323503795415.051639158461367.891401203947817338.27562295662-56.18675938413862141387.19619859393033.8859449424948968.385987078328856.024580189637602CylindricaluniformHighMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic197078.6215810565587
242Carbon Fiber93.270304060151860.317870500456955144468.3657475287851382.598401827967890.9376660847010418108.68756569468-48.51977821348551121354.527889592862841.70226919627127466.065733582440325.703669707507533RectangulardistributedHighShortGoodHighShark Optimizer158378.81348546354856
243Carbon Fiber103.449869778597990.30151926096399681624.7948489505502957.932365355043898.6016252217941412263.574150762619-44.48251578282595125600.487545992072021.90618160560345753.543982184659618.923569902670542Cylindricalpoint loadModerateShortExcellentMediumShark Optimizer156768.41598451723618
244Aluminum59.850246928813660.330359668031098451926.14251190231471039.765000194991476.4626273014935114858.91491755473-52.122000906018826195524.929184118462232.7009872635460441.2093056094494310.20891531546451RectangulardistributedModerateShortPoorLowShark Optimizer616119.81058315170866
245Aluminum145.102202232037370.320833449234803062466.17454043845461458.364348649564692.9341609636624616512.885729684836-46.97636482464479194996.17705374662524.394619825129733.3982700154555212.215211244370117Rectangularpoint loadHighLongPoorMediumShark Optimizer150479.98148748392312
246Aluminum156.236636286722960.313834195351009761611.0951453140658772.583058109846184.910595176038848657.163121623667-54.33301737449769185253.63281485373829.59538559280438752.8520382364397412.23396142686233TapereddistributedModerateShortGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic93365.54861969838592
247Aluminum129.404415842074430.31135748991895242983.299087638119286.11311321780555.9306404966495714852.302540288127-42.52506245084881151435.90200396083425.46752280386751747.40594702787950611.690922072779568Rectangularpoint loadModerateShortGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1524128.88023033746975
248Carbon Fiber159.745592883889120.31022091061891982875.944494102293604.298864272660470.684884126805768044.280517760523-53.19658930819816137196.82547948723357.7268654814335750.2730004637863310.866539282225778CylindricaluniformLowLongExcellentMediumShark Optimizer95496.86733920125826
249Aluminum155.83933013159510.34262524578185881937.1872841391591512.576759049901352.29138350651978619266.927247512023-50.190590906917514177493.240219708943042.19356154759768.2499542669474413.714735079476572RectangularuniformModerateShortGoodHighShark Optimizer1151122.65855766786242
250Titanium124.383905923800340.32989434733209182529.5597341716802718.595071856246755.699147267949035884.309861069101-43.57902714619591118356.347204184572424.91748250241283562.0484823043126645.7246230685096275Rectangularpoint loadLowLongPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic156994.06164767783511
251Carbon Fiber147.063511389359550.313716834498924731586.6715999425744747.992160799381794.4997995016074119655.50934295629-41.63211436747248125838.029208410333157.05551380336092449.420160341291399.031507981102704Rectangularpoint loadLowMediumExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic1340103.58042100009911
252Carbon Fiber138.059676264186520.31684446688413963573.1852291589681358.678270135424891.9351579866169610740.562349915166-40.52579012793008191134.47339477213134.97860255450592665.326918871272875.002665120391389Taperedpoint loadLowMediumExcellentLowChaotic Quantum Genetic1666132.20683382549674
253Carbon Fiber104.094929411745570.33816197398889852555.4841868571651421.392104644935252.2427763962987314297.323214101865-56.965944362029994102036.384318168293020.73053926219736855.5595946156666549.439345941532457TapereddistributedModerateLongPoorMediumShark Optimizer1983108.11524561951418
254Aluminum171.704011260925540.33770892404808963751.192228966798943.99992853406380.313030280027466697.475397037162-42.792750960092874127418.527435236143151.2618990047039636.12587427118738513.533339954964113CylindricaluniformModerateShortPoorHighChaotic Quantum Genetic87984.48499277895189
255Titanium60.4846406682481260.325748465798102571793.997006732732335.235029022696460.1565754901469065085.762895380582-41.626859155023695164442.336388564143448.13298572858370544.2228106022667410.68695838672264Rectangularpoint loadModerateMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic680102.89897110836881
256Aluminum91.889231948958380.335068092577018974171.373814819603731.343757318656859.0993474115540647008.140891272159-43.601039117699905189945.4934563383238.8591266966580969.589755366845186.508198998912061RectangulardistributedLowMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic62274.27080950415265
257Titanium198.512411457750350.325721300013285864005.206019704468691.950798800561461.4122683328711914060.467167154186-49.971827159526924173869.653412405462644.8918094420404240.274208631765896.7720054985989195TapereduniformModerateMediumPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic109652.31034389266972
258Titanium166.396843872452560.34611180378851862035.12985689267771463.51694616631250.64769226790589613087.61878333434-59.62180467301834199589.41156310073928.10207949168496531.39848748207054611.734603870975022Rectangularpoint loadModerateShortPoorLowShark Optimizer157272.85065873217532
259Carbon Fiber151.447396729561350.313068041562994342647.662272489538312.324289068002675.503885601449927783.912358218977-44.92102965073815139328.786707441443734.8155065662586961.508895926338499.599565586502468TapereddistributedHighMediumExcellentLowChaotic Quantum Genetic575144.744777789402
260Titanium168.291186216720350.33577153571899743710.271445655975979.250464868173557.3374112367859255350.723601828506-59.137729284974874112531.16306055433223.94121605774010351.64646968153229514.938447247403403RectangularuniformModerateShortExcellentMediumShark Optimizer156455.5217890109575
261Aluminum141.563604904796760.337963798591012443442.4633663124723482.456554472032592.006045671180449516.56698078591-59.531832084291104190.167584340023638.447050554694949.3249815898223413.50327961146064CylindricaluniformLowMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic809135.9400441070838
262Aluminum156.146653391018560.34481775323740292273.6373521717687265.434146414788564.896561131159317070.264198277648-54.12140128817527180546.06556897932959.2560219889336647.720230681797496.7554112877938435RectangularuniformLowLongGoodHighShark Optimizer1830109.01889951046488
263Aluminum186.352192621224870.33265527528504834258.772765693722968.121813433131574.491073525566767290.61487077061-44.37110429385557100171.589282053232847.0828124210222760.16360801083515514.28696523524599Cylindricalpoint loadHighMediumGoodLowChaotic Quantum Genetic156795.96096866912072
264Titanium77.325317764548420.307866471840512471659.784082054094905.004601105000162.91578046445502514400.176350510319-49.07015680790664125679.45164971082436.4820096209137366.0244461660482513.966945573607797CylindricaldistributedHighMediumExcellentLowShark Optimizer1309140.66903311095058
265Aluminum60.0494871428182360.34078418882288312760.8560586518524300.3032745534545796.3309705831485117257.44453323435-56.41382135140423185533.906617677773040.85201725961023635.1973590721957513.980378160188657TapereduniformModerateMediumGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic1864104.92854012037427
266Carbon Fiber151.95382168233290.32214742467073681702.4318829468336541.396500701095866.005876383531697110.035334122142-53.68156452713198170178.527319012563739.8754798435095349.0712448443388411.394304922861073RectangularuniformModerateLongPoorMediumShark Optimizer851120.8064944586448
267Aluminum173.670203805932570.312141395215256361781.73887271736341155.018773625385661.0811494051426614878.982816786243-46.42044448454856180427.310657708823837.21365230016148535.0416136878693713.876900412908999RectangularuniformModerateShortExcellentMediumShark Optimizer66272.31556737626164
268Titanium83.993832520077970.337501425043324372723.2018500539207797.620218670834751.2254687891538811960.76331784355-53.5141056906284182260.250887354572932.1342184841427562.2528529492272511.42697179252313CylindricaldistributedModerateMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1528119.85236375454163
269Titanium73.148180837775630.343948347462343931942.1599075163656360.683368237054167.269792761420198481.514357385486-53.06464017549114163179.818614643773133.58908163299993530.817791901946936.706978335349341CylindricaluniformHighMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1094124.80323269144964
270Carbon Fiber136.261502844104260.305519535225200531979.95881557067361133.886951050584779.9622329744656212626.428747250233-58.33193197077725171662.45126743423730.19688363663535234.2223798606762714.662507700548101Taperedpoint loadHighMediumGoodMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic761111.95483429623509
271Carbon Fiber186.77046242848620.300636758379914773965.99854697664865.021327529723492.6216701632252813699.36069643242-47.58973876916265117880.215928211442047.9773766269235653.690743145648910.44824349716499Rectangularpoint loadHighLongExcellentHighShark Optimizer122379.61694168958124
272Titanium99.823550314795880.303277583953201264008.920840766815937.066650278163760.9655044082217211454.44961618821-44.31827467032464133690.2936288423940.1902132833187430.64654998494445712.472189443676902RectangulardistributedLowMediumGoodLowShark Optimizer156861.8883706863526
273Carbon Fiber188.009321996894470.34058959942849344089.732370172486373.0269730469085588.2306696851361815740.313681368887-44.09372598500028106962.692917398382137.38943322282601448.6392184953614513.342877624081583Cylindricalpoint loadLowShortGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic191977.57765161557042
274Aluminum64.882897345630170.306244457670973861988.147642988144335.4603126317897565.8081192875876613065.966031441094-49.9439966239004163570.925435004353248.20626858093566435.48650612440831512.91690494737031Taperedpoint loadLowLongPoorHighShark Optimizer1424103.47288828246892
275Aluminum134.097620932934630.33942076904338083482.5451440618344372.503539217428567.1072021939609613118.874797302262-56.15983471174473150685.494495902973745.80585825883025654.6532655516448649.455853114564926CylindricaldistributedHighMediumExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic125066.78528324241148
276Carbon Fiber175.031078994780470.308664384245478043591.6155405575932814.802812181552869.896175082647227386.706014574198-57.202844715305744162535.890709834443241.8114040339545231.143569349492077.71432694676546Cylindricalpoint loadModerateShortPoorHighShark Optimizer87079.7849260433373
277Titanium89.133658462418680.345061350124916453132.4112919882881152.359821225697772.309351286740046230.313598677851-54.8829335670404163297.500203293543931.96217690094704331.459095239153288.998606967637816RectangularuniformModerateMediumPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic118662.6036435743822
278Titanium134.48406935802970.32517464953885233030.4785345729006454.0323110527683686.730078877140847721.772906245542-51.79719496099713142104.65243308172852.70040014976045539.9195121946882514.471794730760012Rectangularpoint loadModerateLongExcellentLowShark Optimizer105296.77927553880457
279Carbon Fiber188.961030152361050.300765369812798673709.1072489331127859.295691646843496.125297275139475443.044418436746-44.820241016673585104524.35655429882643.2112524762361369.152173182160749.80834460069814CylindricaluniformModerateLongPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic192383.620317613261
280Carbon Fiber169.792650059892340.31810573999377413362.6542808212753707.470299677886772.8684925234448615805.846416803606-42.39587478411417165460.6656297243520.89143466557274253.586895681726086.352011466468827CylindricaluniformHighLongPoorMediumShark Optimizer177062.191332570599485
281Titanium137.23509137137620.304496168615025153700.377606847798717.251584943102367.283834391294767000.936857146653-53.829102244576404105017.482889822832546.8366004749554248.4689096517530813.387533006607555RectangulardistributedLowMediumPoorHighShark Optimizer58375.9612560910044
282Aluminum115.293006849191090.31843800802718584125.9368653726251214.196660550432291.94549697472197274.916556316738-57.92185559036089116390.377971210822237.5018603148484445.1095027216149514.085511449205427CylindricaluniformHighMediumPoorMediumShark Optimizer183256.710819002829595
283Carbon Fiber176.522882320042040.30918179204834042793.7421284399325396.668981148629953.333795247830189851.885901686885-40.098808281132484164929.250853476752256.6265636382145864.658508907875059.476010096261849Cylindricalpoint loadModerateMediumExcellentHighShark Optimizer1661125.66561305686342
284Aluminum85.103119175894240.32503201283278532087.27389697673151174.057053207667450.799633599330597280.2239669761675-45.37169072002044127537.775214335623826.97844114139373462.961341802759829.409737797277376Rectangularpoint loadModerateLongGoodMediumShark Optimizer129298.00597854028697
285Carbon Fiber189.535345550574160.33289025839437793966.9330507887244305.079509524053581.1685522657667810784.877875809436-43.41033189411002151313.775883898872225.06535751910434254.8189907227364911.264380748948248RectangulardistributedLowLongGoodMediumShark Optimizer1600147.29283875119353
286Titanium98.986096924317020.34978795727613052846.37156345614541206.067675264759674.216943796293517730.444488559784-42.704273269890095161905.090353161683452.67512391529932437.66212573693725612.653889059725028Rectangularpoint loadHighShortGoodHighChaotic Quantum Genetic634145.33209330225165
287Titanium80.557844568902410.349767449977216543002.6026053460251148.367406903606554.83253878000413614987.596501108343-59.163533778771864174311.153058929373059.1212966991446341.1669553062288810.715935978925739CylindricaluniformModerateShortGoodLowShark Optimizer900144.84186373443015
288Aluminum117.952002550275710.327677640396370652330.819769711209553.736791730515590.4797135261326319486.52817290716-54.61211019163627195308.926066803573249.4648727490812155.53993640098304512.230750280417084TapereduniformModerateMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1369139.42699771695612
289Aluminum155.81916150560370.311293328632876733161.7392868333454922.146692880111667.1789188001066616577.678484371798-48.89323682062665181673.771048739062258.7834686612334334.45397750401427.717805892580085Rectangularpoint loadModerateShortExcellentLowShark Optimizer127186.86101488571046
290Carbon Fiber143.546750836627380.341746032059690843247.88315736194271476.919951961974776.775022787611111865.062747889351-56.81522176851152107849.66975911462737.8224282136817851.672863435417259.722605819991728RectangularuniformHighLongGoodHighShark Optimizer718145.23687533121898
291Titanium148.509096685701170.306086641147195253884.26869943432031393.245631277786377.176248640159068401.037170388068-58.61992262154988126779.12137493023146.7509927125060253.463737185284875.132143030452556Cylindricalpoint loadLowShortGoodLowShark Optimizer79780.20122112826833
292Titanium115.648077877072410.3121683829318452269.49467974520671496.090057215632762.8913719427816317516.761506200004-42.558844475029815117237.222466137172025.77902128246907466.693998159284410.931995698857497CylindricaluniformModerateLongExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic115295.02410278716414
293Carbon Fiber152.192981133749870.305687971627270744029.6462356487896715.81863217480193.8033143764017710520.244343647923-48.03315757848352111051.176029281432535.44333795679527667.8025591979328511.907901225962206Taperedpoint loadHighMediumGoodLowShark Optimizer820132.30481689652333
294Aluminum117.360024458681980.34660531167735623006.1978261623835480.9842653983494661.3373477968496112989.479632856071-42.00980007921311130854.216205004253120.98647278011888862.5836557076358811.90563308816559TapereddistributedModerateMediumExcellentMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1539128.69087941551788
295Carbon Fiber125.243710414576470.31337652634065883683.2529656460171014.279995680954782.4160680071807318236.592028240142-41.40345922066663115182.736140494283726.05471137954610666.311697600613611.899220672036083RectangulardistributedHighLongExcellentMediumShark Optimizer152255.32154775146428
296Titanium81.4020760934470.316380757450701543532.9588411278131391.712996810800994.403121718657948464.038664010153-42.28975119641002119832.194967378083623.263797634778340.8879922085323245.188763578838172Cylindricalpoint loadModerateShortPoorLowChaotic Quantum Genetic109280.86598043542074
297Titanium55.978966368481750.326870866479488932427.39519083792861054.946037889917559.268384486133759363.247661704849-56.90642121061366169993.101154196542427.5628208743786252.356615363608712.13661289432569CylindricaluniformLowMediumExcellentMediumShark Optimizer1522129.82292268067954
298Titanium181.47550390135560.337619113128647842529.2954311346416532.209795616997687.3695562112672815313.349255104666-40.149003561025566168685.082573646272622.14541829428145530.68471783241394511.543812957604953CylindricaluniformLowLongPoorHighShark Optimizer59451.89795828363507
299Aluminum106.476740073764290.32390042285365622295.3590690990013705.359718496594562.5596164988068314826.358818312372-48.31325985071068125409.277724856022326.8750315113735755.766189399156038.521192075532527CylindricaluniformModerateShortExcellentLowShark Optimizer103654.661268230527746
300Carbon Fiber112.797739480375230.30486483459784864062.0808391680516619.813169732377797.6087256621384812367.062895724015-53.50037607230469153441.82601050373931.01292889884713639.5523433695357113.36562092599181RectangularuniformLowMediumExcellentHighChaotic Quantum Genetic1012100.59953325652282
301Titanium150.117060637569580.344144441111975344238.3700894727641259.17079754166973.6744519616714511749.799603298728-48.08308147277026128124.366175003983545.3645486081461261.4052387486834712.854248658142579RectangulardistributedHighMediumPoorMediumChaotic Quantum Genetic1830114.71417920841427