mirror of
https://gitlab.com/Anson-Projects/projects.git
synced 2025-06-16 15:06:53 +00:00
90 KiB
90 KiB
1 | Material Type | E (GPa) | ν | ρ (kg/m³) | Tensile Strength (MPa) | Young’s Modulus | Altitude (m) | Temperature (°C) | Pressure (Pa) | Operational Life (years) | Wing Span (m) | Fuselage Length (m) | Structural Thickness (mm) | Structural Shape | Load Distribution | Vibration Damping | Computational Time | Weight Efficiency | Durability | Quantum Algorithm Type | Number of Iterations | Optimization Time (sec) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | Aluminum | 185.69674587216923 | 0.3077091076893067 | 2730.710453347573 | 1423.8896628761486 | 91.17299288446213 | 15599.655147919875 | -57.4316753428427 | 148360.10745115433 | 37 | 33.200714738611765 | 64.8981493428567 | 13.688270591376993 | Tapered | point load | Low | Short | Excellent | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1568 | 146.8483625712404 |
3 | Titanium | 59.852396308551285 | 0.3091065976511747 | 1969.6701047524516 | 467.4422250027577 | 88.16186018969657 | 12086.883847255816 | -40.72602152301445 | 168254.942831212 | 32 | 36.628837375854935 | 62.93773388897836 | 9.550246323730573 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Long | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1764 | 107.07157146961171 |
4 | Carbon Fiber | 136.37391806872313 | 0.34693239807717946 | 3659.13911868068 | 961.1634225571677 | 55.89916627958678 | 19366.24386815015 | -43.5763296690442 | 161654.15233261226 | 27 | 36.06081428096664 | 56.812967861996306 | 5.026259803862095 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Long | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1707 | 148.14485133157285 |
5 | Aluminum | 103.1404688671567 | 0.3110803842093607 | 3377.9041546502604 | 1432.1332098388214 | 53.71812348404767 | 15975.653098448489 | -54.26445040826743 | 143375.9981752317 | 25 | 58.4709309292062 | 30.477116063096545 | 9.812850176901676 | Cylindrical | distributed | High | Long | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1394 | 72.46312572695285 |
6 | Aluminum | 136.73238012505152 | 0.3081743106150689 | 1859.5278067829097 | 1448.2940589146617 | 86.93776881689828 | 6948.7164403823535 | -41.03878977021339 | 100397.4035199826 | 31 | 51.21656851915226 | 30.515037835310714 | 10.85505636634123 | Tapered | point load | High | Medium | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 630 | 72.55489227802586 |
7 | Aluminum | 142.8293261707048 | 0.3458692800681361 | 3835.2676659121353 | 289.3948599331531 | 95.37520858635656 | 6431.227665179744 | -56.159318961767795 | 176977.5145553468 | 31 | 20.01907763119695 | 65.65169341994012 | 9.711056981697059 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Long | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 845 | 66.4723509826728 |
8 | Aluminum | 180.05288793830337 | 0.32605954095794687 | 2165.6654187122276 | 394.8236151465794 | 97.23435223482802 | 12975.196444997844 | -40.785178256254 | 122496.84181779732 | 22 | 25.641439302803906 | 54.93476557528503 | 8.580532219920899 | Cylindrical | distributed | Low | Short | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1443 | 57.438959985958036 |
9 | Carbon Fiber | 95.46567932146925 | 0.3364791446443523 | 2381.1918865021908 | 918.3375262560851 | 77.54490562644108 | 6402.932149851687 | -59.083534493517206 | 116094.72773801848 | 23 | 27.641114172579595 | 45.86597969323207 | 6.396295653522422 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Medium | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1304 | 136.93256390334258 |
10 | Titanium | 193.33211000100965 | 0.3156223201252317 | 3843.9773642084233 | 832.5522183002187 | 81.40322335846595 | 16974.39460676098 | -53.134688761511086 | 135539.80502332433 | 21 | 34.657051875464425 | 39.971821209190765 | 14.578870208967704 | Tapered | uniform | High | Long | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1124 | 107.67952920733637 |
11 | Carbon Fiber | 125.09339497884484 | 0.3270695448715915 | 3931.5677282158986 | 312.18376766009476 | 95.11438172512086 | 18428.346563804655 | -59.113182716605884 | 189515.1590988675 | 37 | 23.55874400288851 | 39.89937025072916 | 12.239644803414784 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Medium | Excellent | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1195 | 128.01889520720465 |
12 | Titanium | 99.76197200379667 | 0.34219971494269685 | 3802.213663300717 | 1337.0312986856434 | 53.21965321919042 | 19718.0400014506 | -45.667662622288994 | 139306.78626462014 | 38 | 37.87467910718959 | 49.995736339287646 | 14.680648659535029 | Rectangular | uniform | Low | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1442 | 79.20082571877944 |
13 | Aluminum | 143.3125873666309 | 0.33993219975926603 | 2850.5786094242585 | 305.1293941720374 | 95.47654637704724 | 5193.101067257328 | -43.569465368927624 | 123778.86047837434 | 20 | 58.871074482020546 | 64.763644877599 | 12.510552252342098 | Rectangular | point load | High | Long | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 541 | 104.87086654280625 |
14 | Aluminum | 173.97208316924662 | 0.3297927846604411 | 4088.694664139886 | 1214.612784553235 | 61.21369420983725 | 14942.473259534878 | -58.933154133216995 | 128046.04910270477 | 34 | 21.713714162745298 | 67.39587736930224 | 6.02060881973955 | Tapered | point load | Low | Long | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1798 | 60.48475132088802 |
15 | Carbon Fiber | 164.39280107764 | 0.30160684458813486 | 3323.080303973813 | 969.0195401697008 | 70.37974658006833 | 16548.358714079353 | -52.32338621879984 | 122355.92154472703 | 32 | 30.288172070395376 | 65.38914330024781 | 8.442654498895124 | Tapered | point load | Moderate | Medium | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1037 | 58.774870860473825 |
16 | Titanium | 91.1591724557606 | 0.30021029872451355 | 1664.390825278095 | 261.2468675518519 | 87.61404538127476 | 7737.665305560045 | -46.40778002720175 | 126644.23663043186 | 23 | 45.94479356094932 | 66.08393823328004 | 5.928445821198167 | Tapered | point load | Low | Short | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1396 | 72.30942096323649 |
17 | Carbon Fiber | 165.1022287916304 | 0.3008221710583374 | 3555.2175899344197 | 831.5213387322339 | 88.05938513150673 | 15200.805232377954 | -56.678938895369924 | 187245.15496293193 | 35 | 41.175028567582096 | 59.846477301936716 | 11.369122049991104 | Rectangular | point load | High | Long | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1181 | 67.18012070543091 |
18 | Titanium | 183.85220393294023 | 0.3194816302474728 | 2140.532584432867 | 402.78530302256036 | 52.32649195759719 | 9470.54768089762 | -43.50481992939302 | 194043.18213693151 | 38 | 45.668986919770916 | 35.75865924591864 | 7.508387097294733 | Rectangular | point load | High | Medium | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 762 | 91.06840119767335 |
19 | Carbon Fiber | 97.73649000181257 | 0.3465251814972963 | 1650.989863930798 | 1412.7590905269183 | 59.5296989080556 | 9473.487152567275 | -48.69266879369785 | 100593.88273255317 | 29 | 53.88500825939991 | 67.59010105694699 | 5.915049433139105 | Tapered | point load | Low | Medium | Excellent | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1541 | 130.16451419467 |
20 | Titanium | 103.32100834796287 | 0.3251616416637965 | 2063.066243161847 | 731.2444566912928 | 87.39099535485155 | 18773.927987827636 | -51.635418720272 | 136000.4513198292 | 32 | 55.71027444991133 | 35.96461197422321 | 6.202030045517514 | Rectangular | point load | High | Short | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1178 | 109.9248169510528 |
21 | Carbon Fiber | 126.67086383262512 | 0.3184986450753615 | 2748.5350688917533 | 1431.7431910820912 | 66.26139559574396 | 10000.458614177083 | -42.72863794266303 | 160618.24564149286 | 32 | 36.123864085015995 | 68.64675350948136 | 7.9588951429252806 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Short | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 674 | 144.71471248891976 |
22 | Carbon Fiber | 65.83640046245274 | 0.33210439290697624 | 2288.8233594508492 | 1402.923346628862 | 63.30960553904075 | 12889.236306517234 | -44.748384737640826 | 103901.36529063854 | 21 | 55.599758948803355 | 50.2659883520016 | 13.092362933884004 | Tapered | uniform | Low | Long | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1466 | 143.485302485745 |
23 | Aluminum | 76.07339592814992 | 0.33782205516781094 | 3894.8878432032566 | 879.8498363101618 | 57.33068265251317 | 18175.65280786523 | -45.65945623655695 | 148914.5749560104 | 37 | 52.77162727716028 | 30.329511276987343 | 6.363333735735451 | Rectangular | uniform | High | Medium | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 763 | 114.57785713385437 |
24 | Aluminum | 114.30464562492321 | 0.31364898375016864 | 2853.3471534018836 | 1186.4985158007942 | 59.94262741530115 | 15227.771507441645 | -46.325477400382574 | 149505.71095971586 | 35 | 55.99710477557582 | 53.0742741412037 | 12.042902290161347 | Tapered | uniform | Low | Long | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1234 | 63.30789714731612 |
25 | Aluminum | 155.30014125726473 | 0.3463045171622278 | 2372.828437867368 | 1287.364284113898 | 86.1869184630626 | 19429.82668906438 | -56.192926682953505 | 180798.82817886292 | 26 | 52.81414363657311 | 56.23267113133001 | 5.447753801464143 | Cylindrical | uniform | High | Medium | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 1716 | 127.07984141251384 |
26 | Titanium | 89.68185181432807 | 0.34601878545167636 | 3467.4941842232615 | 1244.683293446122 | 75.08398749394509 | 7648.5411822589795 | -53.2587376814376 | 169678.54108113432 | 33 | 55.95672624357594 | 51.802593169938 | 6.507240669764442 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Short | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1800 | 106.0349869724827 |
27 | Carbon Fiber | 94.941326628275 | 0.3292341482313094 | 1984.0315169111295 | 451.39919053154307 | 76.25550943324689 | 18675.48532861378 | -41.92134845163533 | 186516.57343162133 | 22 | 35.753265507287196 | 48.01579948924509 | 13.666356250759645 | Tapered | point load | Low | Medium | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1481 | 140.0233447736726 |
28 | Titanium | 199.81757759681514 | 0.31730427447639625 | 1520.9326830665884 | 887.6698185833585 | 71.57797424272107 | 16849.923868198835 | -43.141478528705484 | 127924.2401907722 | 39 | 37.389348486003996 | 41.313063478347665 | 11.617647747105028 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Long | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1937 | 107.71802469964831 |
29 | Carbon Fiber | 126.1558548149402 | 0.31220459790220234 | 1766.1422357320198 | 1483.2161721750033 | 86.99652446278297 | 6000.560641294601 | -45.22842906320757 | 182374.7355351096 | 33 | 31.345037120332677 | 43.27105731288941 | 6.3104386120918035 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1567 | 62.49753806139737 |
30 | Titanium | 90.49120856396642 | 0.3110594556193396 | 2246.090732707651 | 961.7395527232031 | 51.9364678559415 | 6909.513172344643 | -40.471672166170094 | 120719.48515498136 | 27 | 35.288143033834345 | 50.92233688939321 | 8.077167277113304 | Rectangular | point load | High | Medium | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1178 | 69.96057682332706 |
31 | Carbon Fiber | 174.18302323561682 | 0.3488650862268602 | 2110.4414068867322 | 1415.8447690284972 | 86.97168639992108 | 15470.964231330086 | -48.66796601545295 | 170774.8130660075 | 32 | 49.49157408154812 | 37.357939802083635 | 12.23262699413218 | Cylindrical | distributed | Moderate | Short | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 1688 | 113.78608840480152 |
32 | Carbon Fiber | 50.10324792779846 | 0.3198538099174011 | 3454.20340548934 | 1436.463563476737 | 87.3980256309425 | 13293.297069881495 | -56.033926491614785 | 107368.45344576395 | 32 | 53.65662468200266 | 49.59992953397539 | 13.776411710333175 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Long | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1512 | 66.20427445707013 |
33 | Titanium | 102.59370321158133 | 0.3138365249203013 | 3698.001054697077 | 1031.2893197889362 | 67.8223312665979 | 18551.41433765254 | -48.959965085013394 | 199753.23121456456 | 29 | 39.33409545323259 | 69.1042443948012 | 6.166558380245696 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 599 | 86.20459461383635 |
34 | Carbon Fiber | 179.8601837764895 | 0.3212199485165768 | 4051.815453630391 | 350.3272911377233 | 71.02659886012793 | 7317.398454824679 | -46.00713854401302 | 130432.42864555851 | 26 | 38.43526337354982 | 48.3916031392669 | 12.13650477461984 | Cylindrical | distributed | Low | Long | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1367 | 70.39894477480988 |
35 | Aluminum | 180.31717370858613 | 0.32398970635276614 | 4236.440887210955 | 958.0547929059627 | 90.18694600591681 | 17721.35467467908 | -42.842938469918366 | 138251.0686734774 | 27 | 59.019420804208686 | 62.632726973470895 | 8.801667918699188 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Medium | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1094 | 65.43744200049852 |
36 | Titanium | 83.94742701811707 | 0.34629760413841476 | 1620.5408343974364 | 1410.3053664746371 | 72.45802238788207 | 5974.708676638895 | -40.830608758035396 | 196996.0401135071 | 33 | 49.17695805302832 | 53.11643466648175 | 12.563119463106682 | Rectangular | uniform | High | Long | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1391 | 137.70287344490055 |
37 | Carbon Fiber | 153.7902670450099 | 0.3429334249228698 | 2045.3599432162653 | 1385.5200900536254 | 61.91410700385839 | 7609.827125359874 | -58.14729096847522 | 159994.09590703793 | 20 | 41.969313229517624 | 52.36771876365739 | 5.5222071692582775 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 735 | 118.6915748127189 |
38 | Aluminum | 197.82096452049848 | 0.3119910443413289 | 3375.48918804584 | 364.6478075497559 | 62.48317850458787 | 19962.628912373224 | -53.29185042634573 | 148172.1077459446 | 21 | 46.07165746272892 | 32.80791280140578 | 8.04504780546391 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Short | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1355 | 70.41310363401095 |
39 | Carbon Fiber | 96.49774574338687 | 0.3217234467484825 | 3611.406616621056 | 325.7088403218356 | 62.64219434319173 | 9786.200543337738 | -55.01831751744858 | 189546.53623136744 | 21 | 47.17772993686935 | 35.98127691981561 | 11.272163084709497 | Rectangular | uniform | High | Long | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1537 | 115.93701177580775 |
40 | Carbon Fiber | 67.19368220137531 | 0.3152621385410689 | 3360.8395808477903 | 732.4683875250296 | 85.8852343101693 | 15536.035015799269 | -57.45037399033869 | 103369.01246980573 | 33 | 56.68236905306986 | 60.82838204951429 | 8.793757771476947 | Tapered | point load | Low | Short | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1433 | 108.24052665875041 |
41 | Aluminum | 145.9691592473058 | 0.3279837900648014 | 3047.0471882975553 | 726.5065912160063 | 89.15334170602381 | 7223.092355193023 | -59.63576334379074 | 137622.91619872986 | 20 | 38.919485857087224 | 41.48776407231498 | 5.12701814075527 | Tapered | uniform | High | Short | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1297 | 123.545799633798 |
42 | Titanium | 181.89251206173822 | 0.3045280593704386 | 2172.141626713458 | 1138.6949188296587 | 78.14394236447085 | 18492.477449297206 | -56.53532506341871 | 148901.72944824485 | 31 | 48.33764052937341 | 69.94881322469841 | 7.7962542726683335 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Short | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1673 | 130.23599876249048 |
43 | Aluminum | 180.40832905149895 | 0.3358546592267001 | 3779.305079212863 | 1172.9221585017822 | 90.40283248995459 | 17556.736668685626 | -58.215594813308456 | 137763.017523335 | 33 | 55.04189055551096 | 69.05242236512643 | 14.281592330016922 | Tapered | uniform | High | Short | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1058 | 127.95688319796898 |
44 | Titanium | 139.36204823886553 | 0.3100690811986523 | 4106.413314134352 | 968.8277471766653 | 55.17719662156092 | 7122.928541049403 | -53.213857781209214 | 165453.96780920826 | 20 | 43.576652724591355 | 57.505827135894094 | 9.682589900981457 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Medium | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 656 | 90.94844860339671 |
45 | Aluminum | 51.81017249373506 | 0.3352605710253455 | 2650.0124950999593 | 933.4888213887647 | 73.66971803738434 | 12110.296660994027 | -52.97132452015937 | 109136.38312778754 | 21 | 27.915292837137965 | 30.30623238756448 | 6.8265145781461145 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Medium | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 982 | 67.1710167138295 |
46 | Carbon Fiber | 165.54128690202185 | 0.3346820554806511 | 3000.742299803105 | 710.7813012517802 | 93.72875076281389 | 10280.128630580095 | -48.95614388650211 | 124515.45824555824 | 31 | 24.754208486932235 | 54.408286558798096 | 7.162245260464161 | Tapered | distributed | High | Short | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 860 | 108.83157338856557 |
47 | Carbon Fiber | 75.52636823304476 | 0.34015462408932634 | 2028.168206603846 | 1128.3788637758025 | 79.61096217167413 | 11035.915529704715 | -54.00550478062596 | 174316.02129301603 | 28 | 36.57600065342378 | 31.620390142160417 | 11.014452180626567 | Tapered | point load | High | Medium | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 734 | 81.91398929192813 |
48 | Aluminum | 134.2445815243871 | 0.3396625227478938 | 3213.3167597173288 | 842.3632455072941 | 81.82236594419447 | 15542.71059503579 | -58.37640252071766 | 134366.9232080362 | 20 | 28.430521199066586 | 62.885204620568686 | 12.591542248026117 | Tapered | point load | Moderate | Long | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1590 | 82.87443305515785 |
49 | Carbon Fiber | 51.92589868987134 | 0.3263982078047308 | 3922.946353396984 | 483.71745629058364 | 96.46870507031338 | 16843.764779349054 | -57.479913608505555 | 178008.5725032908 | 28 | 45.05071110181301 | 52.45119994348275 | 5.431629480563175 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Medium | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 925 | 139.55570121612305 |
50 | Aluminum | 52.39584268665441 | 0.3340646956870017 | 2963.779409537177 | 1136.6364040866374 | 64.6066829672252 | 7705.364079862682 | -48.13611673605301 | 105603.54082509266 | 25 | 49.08163939079482 | 31.33994726037191 | 7.280312441015119 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Long | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 809 | 73.3023656715142 |
51 | Carbon Fiber | 67.12419604885464 | 0.34939828315157634 | 2646.2996146619453 | 770.6907871089971 | 95.25364982468582 | 18238.298468368568 | -50.39910153432608 | 141906.4297103032 | 23 | 26.208904671803722 | 62.22923576659143 | 10.024608673320618 | Rectangular | point load | High | Short | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1244 | 113.95656958889435 |
52 | Titanium | 125.0550520763387 | 0.3261607972683329 | 2645.033357748076 | 1158.1524741915118 | 57.85630173746365 | 12984.628009003696 | -51.464052028780955 | 195651.36006806014 | 36 | 47.70085559184646 | 44.837999882052614 | 10.377837987060058 | Tapered | point load | Low | Long | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1004 | 134.25045202845445 |
53 | Aluminum | 106.59597173369147 | 0.30520087566284093 | 2264.5563629256712 | 864.4006439252198 | 53.92352967172894 | 17000.188166578708 | -49.30703328992954 | 113215.00816928872 | 23 | 23.627615800031926 | 60.2312614954618 | 11.395836224702238 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1403 | 148.71885519164908 |
54 | Carbon Fiber | 76.77139880894487 | 0.32288397958796283 | 4488.694619032443 | 851.994855598322 | 70.01921864769697 | 6991.4387878250345 | -46.73002893677631 | 124068.24594056963 | 29 | 46.85763597715996 | 68.89676637113962 | 5.344333864801799 | Tapered | uniform | Low | Long | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 973 | 60.18465465088313 |
55 | Carbon Fiber | 166.62595402942807 | 0.31345617561655154 | 1622.418845601043 | 1178.4546792827118 | 87.57162019021179 | 6496.415503073929 | -50.295794871642926 | 139673.2333180655 | 24 | 46.03284471188195 | 34.79682641759467 | 10.444322753597827 | Tapered | point load | Low | Medium | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 558 | 111.82440330975172 |
56 | Carbon Fiber | 103.17546247576614 | 0.32114119061539603 | 3580.8718343627593 | 921.2736379816258 | 51.15444269077046 | 17763.3555582122 | -45.51593734921981 | 182848.75767669035 | 37 | 40.70869405964362 | 61.55320743576864 | 11.67580067141912 | Tapered | distributed | High | Short | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 889 | 71.70554771821288 |
57 | Titanium | 119.78659312190429 | 0.32202763184925237 | 2633.0727048554845 | 1386.429253706373 | 91.48489335429812 | 13027.527204254908 | -58.6709913401147 | 131722.58665042804 | 26 | 31.570672893927885 | 60.71029548403665 | 11.001914083861738 | Tapered | point load | Moderate | Medium | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 728 | 57.87785554951081 |
58 | Carbon Fiber | 64.7337531399095 | 0.31909696622456507 | 1710.7711742007425 | 1116.224332777372 | 94.59189370682326 | 18630.828820971074 | -49.54321187274624 | 140880.15486580122 | 33 | 44.245890188193215 | 35.06860686103313 | 9.930351982443662 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Medium | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1250 | 62.39023637596573 |
59 | Titanium | 157.1366525376356 | 0.33778113619004196 | 4229.202795597148 | 1008.3434995394355 | 67.26946754131265 | 11875.459658007705 | -47.26416892525209 | 158625.7928603336 | 35 | 55.37448336519795 | 57.532373897943785 | 13.725027226744846 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1268 | 95.69211755015316 |
60 | Carbon Fiber | 96.25352808892958 | 0.3340331363150605 | 3832.486081712602 | 579.7298824255677 | 80.1652973771188 | 7190.744253400046 | -58.649408845821426 | 124270.02953366433 | 28 | 38.78882045408136 | 64.59913025285542 | 8.5736110339123 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 786 | 67.10415210554338 |
61 | Titanium | 125.49581854757568 | 0.3018495625761281 | 1989.1734798654365 | 518.0519335461158 | 75.20019144810344 | 9020.01724669529 | -52.79323553442098 | 183726.16344585412 | 20 | 55.68568630989571 | 58.48089864262715 | 14.600653945697252 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Medium | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 755 | 117.73648649644136 |
62 | Titanium | 79.78677028932746 | 0.30896032228873604 | 3329.290517677895 | 1256.8229478892729 | 72.15788651431193 | 14371.929990655526 | -44.05166669513029 | 144302.9881317668 | 31 | 44.01368292712951 | 66.20627568082767 | 10.429486165318567 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Short | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1895 | 55.141667030479894 |
63 | Carbon Fiber | 174.5840352198053 | 0.33112916896265276 | 4301.732871849848 | 549.4727803921394 | 56.74196490405457 | 9426.797302187802 | -56.97075114852104 | 120238.36495844682 | 34 | 52.4147397242101 | 59.157072021272796 | 12.497721685851827 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Long | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1939 | 72.3663482379493 |
64 | Carbon Fiber | 145.7099592652728 | 0.34483513546056216 | 3870.51631014997 | 1103.9638862408856 | 83.31506980357005 | 8580.075154748785 | -58.316830925257385 | 139575.78888199083 | 29 | 31.08678954978157 | 64.79769191426828 | 11.303787498352008 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Short | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 994 | 98.5768274353511 |
65 | Titanium | 62.352603928118285 | 0.33806682374225683 | 2756.991599697687 | 1120.9216400700225 | 82.00387275234948 | 5216.132976166924 | -47.68758944534671 | 181099.04950867628 | 32 | 52.45576694281669 | 53.274202247818664 | 9.712069365189631 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Long | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 580 | 61.7731919120438 |
66 | Aluminum | 141.93751129688212 | 0.32683270312848717 | 2936.1115114383197 | 1153.3311641867906 | 93.56600255321447 | 7128.339269199193 | -55.48393041486737 | 131970.97097416312 | 34 | 24.149395692653115 | 47.762827674298286 | 9.210452512591086 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Short | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1595 | 51.452166808289505 |
67 | Carbon Fiber | 80.11119206609943 | 0.32142582077929227 | 2780.959556192543 | 293.6230924046978 | 97.16729505454217 | 14708.638971238977 | -41.62487786940113 | 143689.05143463542 | 25 | 40.560241141608 | 61.4057757343753 | 13.166632656263959 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Medium | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 831 | 126.86057157156615 |
68 | Aluminum | 64.92304702426978 | 0.34078484729801434 | 1530.4764333454066 | 1312.2815580517256 | 53.05601350850335 | 14262.350117018757 | -47.226391365644176 | 180417.57613633777 | 33 | 30.03782265391196 | 48.68335712306381 | 14.681935967626739 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Medium | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1101 | 84.01353425744054 |
69 | Carbon Fiber | 120.73161331968106 | 0.30916322166882615 | 1924.3483516533702 | 806.3010402045561 | 62.458857360571606 | 19741.455801564058 | -45.174906886232286 | 145163.25407416176 | 23 | 31.16073663050145 | 48.79943611108367 | 6.747584948497522 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Long | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 953 | 121.447874572892 |
70 | Aluminum | 83.31166557697277 | 0.34990396534913865 | 2531.4267219475387 | 1443.0062005444856 | 84.33254357697504 | 18259.95440369423 | -40.02748539344467 | 168238.46736031948 | 36 | 56.31348225403329 | 55.113127109416624 | 10.321809275902819 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Short | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1239 | 93.69451577385689 |
71 | Titanium | 68.2987780009954 | 0.33928495806909714 | 2066.240478505781 | 1446.145111100128 | 70.77653645006933 | 6071.200278298396 | -54.743288070763846 | 122164.36390650568 | 27 | 34.06481834869423 | 61.00349411412256 | 6.798012909150933 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Long | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 737 | 97.38853897247955 |
72 | Carbon Fiber | 181.05770111959808 | 0.3200286085935296 | 4322.098351215337 | 775.3376344149037 | 59.9982895061711 | 8346.319941714093 | -43.61098151450741 | 163364.78104961774 | 26 | 36.71577854616624 | 40.78776598274473 | 10.809703985386053 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Short | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1663 | 144.36523752594871 |
73 | Carbon Fiber | 199.32331858444866 | 0.32346724082797357 | 3641.35929435735 | 914.8748181950555 | 70.1282059128773 | 9471.04950912469 | -57.88165586225057 | 102917.22746541076 | 29 | 54.06943052454709 | 67.95267604495393 | 8.603210229781345 | Rectangular | point load | High | Medium | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1866 | 128.12058805649917 |
74 | Aluminum | 193.81278082016019 | 0.3198583748438536 | 3107.523429895602 | 351.8486478078985 | 92.09031336503685 | 11572.685577560882 | -59.83909144111157 | 186846.3033952424 | 36 | 41.38891291711869 | 30.01276768280777 | 10.869309077790453 | Tapered | point load | Moderate | Long | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1679 | 130.78437675187058 |
75 | Aluminum | 158.04281154753926 | 0.33081362759964644 | 2181.8215049067903 | 1387.5060642485632 | 75.06953467814637 | 16022.430938517125 | -41.855856336011506 | 129574.30789275766 | 25 | 23.169391947340607 | 66.53384504277753 | 8.99118465569181 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1914 | 63.81812421794935 |
76 | Aluminum | 123.00463978788652 | 0.33586229327791195 | 4298.405766018375 | 282.5212407400989 | 87.17874319708542 | 12006.848061767763 | -44.009619917183535 | 145311.13755185576 | 37 | 28.163491005785506 | 44.11594529694576 | 13.295317472826362 | Cylindrical | uniform | High | Short | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1505 | 103.34248167878721 |
77 | Carbon Fiber | 157.24982810270237 | 0.32764424037515655 | 3997.664360423798 | 1161.743177819044 | 83.2356802529196 | 14777.163141768651 | -42.83664359993419 | 179565.24814722297 | 25 | 29.865087363376656 | 34.92962217771948 | 11.89974562572987 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Medium | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 1049 | 134.16263742144548 |
78 | Aluminum | 199.79873562642683 | 0.33803079150185766 | 4155.848078633603 | 1047.7539568528498 | 96.00398373760461 | 10661.533557527062 | -55.046293817026466 | 135523.91567529185 | 38 | 50.9082558210664 | 61.61807493409016 | 8.58993668384335 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Medium | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 960 | 81.88715670615426 |
79 | Carbon Fiber | 51.62875007673623 | 0.3342905973286316 | 2918.839606894168 | 432.2239487762512 | 97.0458149273556 | 6765.488962142561 | -58.56350200026297 | 136899.07557651523 | 27 | 24.780620834562757 | 51.01257541212661 | 14.880442216015128 | Rectangular | point load | High | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 812 | 142.45243956038541 |
80 | Titanium | 102.57024885672254 | 0.3484051237672955 | 4401.575223887234 | 1371.2895375023656 | 98.45283912861181 | 15413.802583061055 | -55.461850649184385 | 163609.72059587543 | 31 | 21.884151641735553 | 47.42107690466422 | 10.660588818362577 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Medium | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 960 | 138.89526786823666 |
81 | Carbon Fiber | 166.79426948269122 | 0.3335127162317976 | 3496.223750158945 | 1078.6697752843484 | 78.59502822969206 | 5970.85780914429 | -57.7377967981293 | 186699.14141683932 | 30 | 42.98340911174206 | 51.01525554910158 | 7.888442714256309 | Tapered | point load | Moderate | Long | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 616 | 112.30862806344285 |
82 | Aluminum | 109.69766873153114 | 0.31801603475679024 | 2581.6527658101213 | 1121.0376109773708 | 53.73946761636116 | 16203.24088097327 | -46.51206699841739 | 186324.04913003984 | 23 | 51.53347587433504 | 35.04235440481522 | 13.818059038320515 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Medium | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1732 | 140.40738772801836 |
83 | Aluminum | 92.51010519210476 | 0.33138124583134165 | 1632.2891527791583 | 931.896558964996 | 85.60604314012227 | 18867.816225294133 | -59.74363383837469 | 156542.4822601062 | 38 | 53.52866457879076 | 66.38635187320048 | 8.129975182447827 | Tapered | point load | High | Short | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 677 | 87.73729944008977 |
84 | Titanium | 119.94872430886215 | 0.3339047877477086 | 2304.076833176831 | 288.8296542647375 | 77.60078951126592 | 15604.603059646399 | -43.85067458113683 | 184574.92855529767 | 37 | 54.71041407453699 | 54.91931164346501 | 8.098797320047872 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Medium | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1391 | 108.13528150327238 |
85 | Carbon Fiber | 56.68633838128914 | 0.32036580986755664 | 3093.380984300831 | 1164.1480633247634 | 64.42196516710544 | 19367.912280099918 | -46.38144919864643 | 161609.34012628978 | 26 | 54.68767473477626 | 69.96330333545606 | 14.107125159585612 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Short | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 637 | 145.4953148704685 |
86 | Titanium | 136.02442335005577 | 0.3199764670147615 | 1654.0993391467273 | 1466.861573890748 | 92.47496036789065 | 19004.393704124144 | -42.43799816750993 | 139824.25059880555 | 38 | 39.82430060173187 | 45.044455244858426 | 7.982842640112154 | Rectangular | uniform | Low | Short | Excellent | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1610 | 128.33100661294037 |
87 | Aluminum | 67.17496879224193 | 0.3432686355486503 | 4313.892014825285 | 1442.3889221347029 | 59.439437942709105 | 12547.280586836852 | -56.70300091882989 | 122613.55387946786 | 26 | 46.33755399005969 | 48.13829406691694 | 14.263387219328788 | Tapered | point load | Low | Medium | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1033 | 98.94293905157 |
88 | Titanium | 82.87817801366498 | 0.3364986273785943 | 3316.797728932426 | 332.338118288678 | 84.75798008974391 | 16535.54795771488 | -40.580372581811375 | 104663.96178678896 | 39 | 52.640091096034844 | 62.984983298315726 | 9.40585206861043 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Long | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 919 | 110.05412004922044 |
89 | Carbon Fiber | 145.2899370200497 | 0.3008297340892527 | 2589.8562861471873 | 728.9221948628576 | 67.23555362907157 | 16770.01891939393 | -56.28908635999404 | 129616.19365729274 | 27 | 32.74711035214018 | 31.12747054097595 | 8.523971537937605 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Medium | Excellent | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 926 | 122.07972737777696 |
90 | Titanium | 76.91418830744459 | 0.33826609074533237 | 3963.0813739323544 | 397.58419480499026 | 78.57370830972161 | 5841.3062673969625 | -53.721357645780365 | 180257.3183196313 | 28 | 24.618407784865166 | 45.49821942595951 | 12.216320186765017 | Tapered | uniform | High | Medium | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1022 | 54.70428535617845 |
91 | Titanium | 84.17935105262524 | 0.3121802578619319 | 3360.370948905229 | 1318.8159656985772 | 65.9688845363055 | 15335.306645973911 | -47.97805863066143 | 121387.67032258914 | 28 | 26.30740068435225 | 47.336787835427664 | 7.5084923787657 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Medium | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 573 | 72.12455130423055 |
92 | Titanium | 179.83541624953236 | 0.3089427341261053 | 3416.5371445981073 | 886.7308167438717 | 96.59360043528862 | 18382.662411409477 | -48.845825048941734 | 193147.05775591894 | 34 | 45.99003059791956 | 61.53420164324196 | 6.367703466391232 | Cylindrical | uniform | High | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1499 | 127.21410070781467 |
93 | Aluminum | 162.625495920712 | 0.34379908882373145 | 3551.899938834394 | 1017.1737632298411 | 80.00480642199898 | 10712.328185207765 | -48.0877281371544 | 128374.04457831135 | 38 | 57.62580373031115 | 32.30543520662526 | 14.273024190599045 | Tapered | uniform | Low | Medium | Excellent | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1014 | 141.90362306016485 |
94 | Carbon Fiber | 93.56137557852627 | 0.3163487031851667 | 4222.337339056994 | 514.4395642182785 | 54.43976358531143 | 11032.831741271959 | -41.884592228717985 | 102086.06251726026 | 32 | 53.365492590325125 | 63.844669401481056 | 10.755981578628298 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Short | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1189 | 120.31741367105886 |
95 | Titanium | 125.94395330817927 | 0.3259928433063592 | 2652.4227651285696 | 575.1940175827654 | 79.10872460559003 | 7906.255859700976 | -51.43582154312202 | 146497.77021328296 | 27 | 34.090633770635144 | 50.12324392465645 | 7.3928860970612265 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Short | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1824 | 113.22197585726792 |
96 | Titanium | 163.12294928775628 | 0.30126109970578324 | 2170.8433544605896 | 909.2615728393552 | 64.41411434892595 | 6197.414138580061 | -49.2075455346522 | 128914.25648613147 | 32 | 30.29136717398812 | 32.21171982739105 | 12.118967907711234 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1350 | 92.44591253858923 |
97 | Carbon Fiber | 124.07665122545002 | 0.32893581020939155 | 3999.5069650745954 | 684.1858643302327 | 80.27074353339084 | 15217.69602083406 | -46.71645249540837 | 186377.7591058199 | 21 | 52.67688881465139 | 67.60770061778126 | 8.150328014686327 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Short | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1365 | 124.71678851700949 |
98 | Aluminum | 57.26214531286442 | 0.33313405784661976 | 4106.8894617291435 | 403.6951804141105 | 58.747872244021636 | 15493.47937763715 | -42.207651651908385 | 115400.70419731943 | 31 | 35.019743601559256 | 62.619052149578394 | 8.951652323766794 | Tapered | uniform | Low | Short | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1811 | 114.77977201388268 |
99 | Carbon Fiber | 179.806790085297 | 0.31449725982427434 | 3673.8332285660745 | 1262.1456347480912 | 74.31979786798422 | 10447.365730917183 | -50.1853252905379 | 191436.5860863601 | 24 | 46.84923201328618 | 47.22423838667454 | 13.331945677199382 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Medium | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 640 | 106.15181505077253 |
100 | Titanium | 147.76877694911695 | 0.31368561994369654 | 3738.646001243673 | 1034.679589037522 | 87.38104743710042 | 8957.27656659461 | -50.694209202406846 | 166086.75240033862 | 25 | 21.3756835353019 | 69.44189384744575 | 13.520506833772721 | Cylindrical | distributed | High | Medium | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1689 | 106.04616787902143 |
101 | Aluminum | 52.174883898308615 | 0.3053455482679295 | 2963.2478566728014 | 1260.4231306899558 | 82.6413789648906 | 7744.957008410021 | -58.762015592894045 | 147178.03376333995 | 33 | 27.126628484107215 | 39.40804648774786 | 6.251924591518111 | Tapered | point load | High | Long | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1965 | 134.68943585110935 |
102 | Titanium | 184.43893324273958 | 0.3427247400135462 | 3081.6114320085817 | 1012.4114283442904 | 79.85587036613865 | 17552.14089531356 | -43.21395269339199 | 173357.29494532978 | 24 | 23.833245617461394 | 58.61892467502662 | 11.710335336488098 | Tapered | point load | Low | Long | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1435 | 148.7771228636147 |
103 | Titanium | 135.63836284704215 | 0.3380005478387557 | 1600.1814750305803 | 782.2510413637744 | 91.02812343570162 | 5654.629158427554 | -46.11129129115784 | 130299.80419475633 | 37 | 40.166559348207464 | 51.838038739461965 | 10.84089152020642 | Cylindrical | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 846 | 139.97693553342418 |
104 | Carbon Fiber | 76.79954485132303 | 0.3350277545428916 | 2450.1822039189074 | 1386.9929699618187 | 82.54336970444888 | 14703.58215175283 | -56.31346256463422 | 140125.7089955663 | 30 | 27.2340450603772 | 48.920422879043585 | 7.789585518853858 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Short | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1907 | 92.43929081236843 |
105 | Aluminum | 60.48444947107433 | 0.33504309768839946 | 2183.992958975346 | 782.5467882314107 | 59.85878441448475 | 7301.053983427482 | -53.88347973151224 | 126736.58702552057 | 24 | 54.67517617187244 | 68.50712184920992 | 6.0708501885579915 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1721 | 108.49183953081575 |
106 | Carbon Fiber | 90.49154343604896 | 0.33222096025808984 | 2208.6714016493424 | 413.8914061824411 | 99.39376308501396 | 12125.377621674106 | -44.539279122247294 | 115139.12207527022 | 38 | 39.08638647645702 | 57.8975503513143 | 12.206436604463606 | Cylindrical | distributed | High | Medium | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 524 | 77.1825197184895 |
107 | Titanium | 91.55282762372312 | 0.31519326239074646 | 1529.522483135766 | 636.3811425366549 | 54.805216814441465 | 6550.204949242153 | -58.31718693262403 | 184320.13305422163 | 23 | 47.21949681630108 | 53.47104998593006 | 12.949744147157727 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Long | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 740 | 144.65566043534244 |
108 | Aluminum | 85.9902686912848 | 0.3479715189050339 | 3964.347313215337 | 645.2232108471612 | 92.7477027144372 | 17429.68411424043 | -49.630410373214644 | 139443.1219999463 | 37 | 52.542790082799335 | 66.65746739575405 | 14.775731161383984 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Long | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 633 | 131.80829509282373 |
109 | Carbon Fiber | 61.851208160031796 | 0.31500071203921787 | 3714.0441049746532 | 534.1300758827197 | 95.35821777486544 | 5376.9094436591495 | -43.67594480135925 | 120686.64921333164 | 35 | 50.24890810469663 | 48.781151674233314 | 6.738799006066547 | Cylindrical | distributed | Moderate | Short | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1394 | 57.76785847832193 |
110 | Aluminum | 89.98176308928669 | 0.32693860723453544 | 2476.648622188361 | 773.9811560496805 | 75.97551587432388 | 8513.151285149126 | -41.97345649364107 | 195790.86991082787 | 33 | 52.155499868931926 | 47.50121353603428 | 13.533282271009968 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Long | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1926 | 142.0687875584573 |
111 | Titanium | 114.58792068307095 | 0.34717988729928595 | 3548.066634951153 | 472.26818044919537 | 60.825413582155406 | 12397.296734391202 | -44.96809602863618 | 109252.97538818988 | 35 | 35.252806652311996 | 49.52409876357566 | 6.277228607325734 | Cylindrical | uniform | High | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1979 | 141.38383190273504 |
112 | Carbon Fiber | 133.55386129779845 | 0.32334833485864556 | 3610.7854629797057 | 535.7100344478897 | 92.02116903033095 | 5813.421316815419 | -49.03787996966923 | 109574.01124777614 | 38 | 48.06791232833086 | 36.83456013318051 | 11.127192618083626 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Short | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1449 | 125.03889027541749 |
113 | Titanium | 66.47947743957862 | 0.34274986274584646 | 3846.3888902281137 | 538.455680488003 | 88.48411659832087 | 7811.667803370031 | -48.7320001610111 | 155470.41133333242 | 34 | 32.09122566917729 | 44.356764077724236 | 10.573351661330681 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Long | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1708 | 86.59310520121974 |
114 | Aluminum | 77.86174515976937 | 0.31538870313870704 | 3896.0462222753663 | 1163.108793508014 | 71.04666375140258 | 18302.015784343395 | -57.78311731623569 | 150027.95122863638 | 32 | 32.040264708994044 | 50.409246614630526 | 5.260121543019829 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Long | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 810 | 98.60631343370214 |
115 | Aluminum | 112.2761561644197 | 0.31800814427160484 | 2411.1353541531134 | 467.4800418816834 | 88.49263921322083 | 15107.823364204856 | -53.9863382600782 | 175355.21250206657 | 27 | 26.476670055259458 | 39.535529477919845 | 6.470289674258533 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1076 | 67.4946347328466 |
116 | Aluminum | 187.6444669219642 | 0.3314288214629405 | 2791.0183735298915 | 1414.6902905608565 | 84.66259471749068 | 11895.22624081189 | -56.49351242659862 | 151452.58012154154 | 31 | 43.61267531111008 | 36.91962405784078 | 12.305670374205134 | Cylindrical | distributed | Low | Medium | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1356 | 112.8758049224953 |
117 | Titanium | 154.13328143134243 | 0.33111131221019163 | 2368.758026252045 | 923.719728572155 | 67.57499243290658 | 16940.13352251224 | -41.05446756842128 | 134482.63858802232 | 34 | 49.52628463656483 | 39.02193207855869 | 13.239061626007185 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Short | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1502 | 90.24037707766176 |
118 | Titanium | 89.77361408449609 | 0.332432621130794 | 3367.8961165529226 | 1435.4026681062542 | 75.21817109964186 | 15295.496048689403 | -57.47851364286974 | 151666.24913247133 | 30 | 31.814791207783134 | 69.82145532549033 | 9.523130203191599 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Short | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1402 | 76.87656310879599 |
119 | Titanium | 197.69307184406665 | 0.34847870226876165 | 1570.68586653003 | 1447.3412947714603 | 72.6580890863014 | 17361.399115659715 | -48.06052289673833 | 141548.5735483423 | 36 | 40.53832710320906 | 39.47352070233924 | 13.26296515992648 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Medium | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1348 | 83.4801248818049 |
120 | Titanium | 87.51386046381967 | 0.34323917107856666 | 1777.3619797734766 | 1129.8116135539394 | 66.91209293243304 | 19384.641940425056 | -42.17199580752094 | 138340.7525779543 | 36 | 35.400767712690104 | 60.68266514096644 | 5.123799088300558 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Long | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1821 | 86.73927123073273 |
121 | Aluminum | 174.53868025738296 | 0.309029096088993 | 1643.5731187737154 | 935.3082644773463 | 58.564197636185405 | 11611.316386978557 | -44.2779567902355 | 189740.60695258476 | 31 | 43.542310762718316 | 60.699682024753855 | 9.895327791074955 | Cylindrical | distributed | Low | Short | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1518 | 124.96019751647364 |
122 | Titanium | 134.69888492674067 | 0.3431704340349757 | 3309.188097628775 | 284.21645523888714 | 66.05671149485364 | 9611.413062072319 | -57.950069664464536 | 177773.2469550484 | 32 | 32.84500792754571 | 30.43854297918614 | 7.940841423962398 | Cylindrical | distributed | Moderate | Long | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 594 | 111.85652966282001 |
123 | Carbon Fiber | 105.16066405920549 | 0.32772051146388786 | 3305.2576172329027 | 268.37133122959466 | 50.42456767106934 | 10441.975487963136 | -46.75652902792134 | 103581.23260983427 | 26 | 25.39052461488651 | 37.81677994499889 | 6.0937220031791615 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1218 | 84.15458419080369 |
124 | Aluminum | 97.13744338926156 | 0.33959099806880455 | 2255.456180250895 | 553.3538432075684 | 52.23798856961911 | 7760.888281471534 | -42.99502435634451 | 147666.85931994775 | 30 | 41.19061854781824 | 51.64792381811826 | 14.21017510417067 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Long | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1178 | 136.4119098818287 |
125 | Titanium | 192.6595686606406 | 0.3378370964951013 | 3475.1566421289217 | 689.3456752618644 | 93.74280834696685 | 5147.811439144733 | -43.11403607341548 | 152409.2263032784 | 35 | 27.139271591604622 | 58.04510376678871 | 7.743057042050042 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Medium | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1971 | 123.02089026723817 |
126 | Carbon Fiber | 196.68552330675885 | 0.3112854530417988 | 2104.677578174032 | 1349.3894577109115 | 60.88509182466303 | 19749.57673470555 | -41.159506382576694 | 152536.9691155363 | 33 | 58.506424283069826 | 64.4285735515553 | 6.522153852040402 | Tapered | uniform | Low | Long | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1361 | 66.391583625597 |
127 | Aluminum | 183.8906167180615 | 0.30768025250247594 | 2792.9898542986843 | 432.0151760907893 | 64.35188629950419 | 12449.436906372677 | -50.047748024349914 | 154025.39874271565 | 25 | 42.27675846187081 | 60.388431969762735 | 5.978819853403826 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Short | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1951 | 114.86525085726123 |
128 | Aluminum | 75.02629862638626 | 0.303493906873094 | 3712.984129576242 | 483.7489935226571 | 73.50664046847064 | 13766.919044327262 | -56.578325577555596 | 183421.97472504195 | 34 | 53.34371532134881 | 31.36615983313861 | 11.065663369285133 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 941 | 93.87709462046075 |
129 | Aluminum | 148.17507046870642 | 0.30343347859179376 | 4144.1534229696335 | 889.591682711022 | 96.17229743492592 | 9651.934666546655 | -42.79316945644997 | 138332.17240194642 | 31 | 48.08123193665104 | 47.29526449915541 | 13.135265800208934 | Tapered | point load | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1012 | 97.52940579142154 |
130 | Carbon Fiber | 54.47272134203694 | 0.31775527155064764 | 3460.8322143698115 | 1036.8101047882842 | 83.06447492636715 | 14440.62966348379 | -45.08295472893391 | 167130.18215741497 | 24 | 52.12206225137531 | 53.64209733938181 | 14.835461010921428 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Short | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1029 | 98.48692606574215 |
131 | Aluminum | 184.26998322860376 | 0.32969237437234233 | 3985.231446371762 | 1206.1870017156148 | 86.57718037264968 | 10894.644347613863 | -47.022903257793324 | 155604.47276225704 | 21 | 28.629552749952126 | 59.578394373905454 | 14.271975743658572 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Short | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1239 | 122.80685546103992 |
132 | Carbon Fiber | 139.02043427925273 | 0.3250081129516541 | 4291.927911430152 | 1130.599677413748 | 68.50457570204802 | 5645.495309064314 | -48.00680390378453 | 165496.35507062078 | 31 | 22.159731033816257 | 57.5700005347477 | 5.350588884653103 | Rectangular | uniform | High | Long | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 916 | 122.16155333019158 |
133 | Titanium | 121.23889060685343 | 0.3233584513976819 | 3048.947946973595 | 490.7853741011255 | 82.93802289260796 | 12672.684476010534 | -55.43245509249938 | 181295.12031100813 | 36 | 41.56207083716204 | 37.952535846738094 | 11.808620138399139 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1490 | 52.00685457980736 |
134 | Carbon Fiber | 103.74718622276833 | 0.31558285347157594 | 1835.9898025286757 | 850.2698378048267 | 90.69701663013859 | 18223.966410806264 | -40.414440592247686 | 120916.40444077617 | 23 | 34.6880037364989 | 63.0193588779259 | 7.244540051765682 | Rectangular | point load | High | Short | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 829 | 75.19060715180943 |
135 | Carbon Fiber | 192.59185793082554 | 0.33329294562810163 | 2645.173561643849 | 511.522547469404 | 56.693247701721454 | 17944.279026943692 | -42.211968491519755 | 193557.6107908364 | 21 | 34.657376347991004 | 61.20179547270853 | 7.899245459553135 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Short | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1419 | 118.47300008219133 |
136 | Carbon Fiber | 53.17476807403847 | 0.319632638691402 | 2002.345274060352 | 535.4901513077143 | 91.09122148112104 | 19286.592328659746 | -59.66907516208308 | 150487.07623444742 | 23 | 24.257700888603356 | 65.52094792140119 | 13.676073300570717 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Long | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 798 | 130.21788948829868 |
137 | Carbon Fiber | 109.4221612742347 | 0.321606442736265 | 2046.8231193278575 | 705.9309864325063 | 64.09218413965239 | 5455.518387373402 | -47.4582094452839 | 173146.81711710396 | 38 | 48.53483532809835 | 57.67071238743965 | 11.27161216136317 | Tapered | point load | Low | Medium | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 868 | 147.3923714934731 |
138 | Carbon Fiber | 105.00083187385584 | 0.338745285280319 | 4406.600109697671 | 1309.3483268566483 | 93.16135003766627 | 13484.513327977136 | -59.974258571539366 | 149388.18878492917 | 26 | 39.81018896151467 | 66.25991266248322 | 11.462097690084299 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Short | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1085 | 116.47401671538692 |
139 | Carbon Fiber | 139.12998647371603 | 0.333578222945554 | 3872.9331918241382 | 1130.5249883630433 | 59.96522904798391 | 15058.745505322488 | -40.781461829059864 | 164561.10536244523 | 21 | 30.311696149100385 | 66.85171521480873 | 12.576601361707985 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Short | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 642 | 108.18021051868077 |
140 | Titanium | 178.34292650583944 | 0.3285825688928668 | 4041.218324251428 | 747.4292689294091 | 61.04419314308945 | 15747.358358155669 | -59.619443238050074 | 186124.71965772333 | 20 | 43.99388358988678 | 61.52432363292897 | 8.986222935906731 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Short | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1488 | 92.13461998585927 |
141 | Carbon Fiber | 89.06488164856773 | 0.32006218767672806 | 2265.009788081885 | 400.53401807257075 | 89.25179337509009 | 19360.45310237301 | -52.24926922162031 | 136357.07150351602 | 35 | 31.555602869269332 | 55.4582377628179 | 12.179902476548945 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1593 | 61.39788768823497 |
142 | Aluminum | 114.08455086521978 | 0.32858606778014876 | 2579.618700241688 | 1096.2366018135808 | 50.75744203920824 | 15770.722855352524 | -46.777237406433414 | 162497.42222998396 | 21 | 37.26007962902769 | 58.78784355457558 | 8.494933543287914 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1233 | 91.93645735693049 |
143 | Carbon Fiber | 119.68300207223835 | 0.31872415997662584 | 3433.1545782232597 | 1371.8886537867509 | 79.76975604944536 | 6967.806137314897 | -55.096142053456326 | 112462.27200257254 | 31 | 22.97038339587685 | 56.584240315561246 | 6.375768310642897 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Long | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1423 | 148.97420523569332 |
144 | Carbon Fiber | 132.9939949539904 | 0.34479639069079776 | 3476.4041108633046 | 923.2408217418285 | 67.85569849854267 | 18175.71287544536 | -46.65734817258223 | 157846.96752188334 | 31 | 46.32742730521771 | 67.2446920235183 | 10.686985080167831 | Cylindrical | distributed | Low | Short | Excellent | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1802 | 122.90192889070134 |
145 | Carbon Fiber | 60.62543350660732 | 0.31598988605433687 | 2390.486804725004 | 1056.0027999917515 | 97.28037847255223 | 19538.86506732287 | -43.711810468025206 | 173937.42421265919 | 24 | 38.40995074675583 | 53.18993548995866 | 8.732877172504182 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 932 | 131.91397502133577 |
146 | Titanium | 69.2688454399015 | 0.3352042186907277 | 4408.555860765388 | 423.79333469019167 | 85.96018534848358 | 6535.025753933452 | -51.49850969731044 | 182419.4302594776 | 21 | 57.02087172437106 | 69.69072102638613 | 12.524962426554502 | Tapered | point load | High | Short | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 949 | 56.536142251083575 |
147 | Titanium | 175.7383943982463 | 0.3497576507072271 | 1772.625270027273 | 1450.2706626931445 | 68.07486412129451 | 15654.748781061939 | -47.82957670374314 | 103193.68279042256 | 27 | 50.343969396526795 | 33.195537528343834 | 14.445669216834713 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Medium | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1775 | 96.96868840261266 |
148 | Aluminum | 92.17369017894106 | 0.32231219649848636 | 3547.270666909043 | 346.72006006272755 | 64.868176460171 | 9447.543984281649 | -49.20214419374315 | 128141.72380604527 | 26 | 47.3037150671765 | 63.33195723989284 | 7.060983369885894 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Long | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1537 | 141.12887351646413 |
149 | Aluminum | 194.72876608043916 | 0.3498260631553911 | 4387.803113290621 | 1228.0939581358534 | 62.68229112749881 | 9416.925001688753 | -48.48670140557605 | 141100.42942696993 | 31 | 48.782923420232535 | 53.357820390327134 | 11.49624403543298 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Short | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1971 | 116.59133508826464 |
150 | Carbon Fiber | 166.5605235168601 | 0.33298603678933925 | 3292.0130106779766 | 490.64558064833886 | 60.72870111858731 | 7476.652857763972 | -47.519886799846894 | 151279.47781259433 | 26 | 32.84029556814817 | 47.352715240403185 | 7.615954699090288 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Medium | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1959 | 141.50475362786983 |
151 | Carbon Fiber | 136.40483856492244 | 0.33029049320389037 | 2073.105157809348 | 517.2042154289202 | 94.05234441120234 | 16722.14045369842 | -44.43309736464278 | 129883.17028628067 | 25 | 27.749223871916534 | 36.13515156884917 | 5.137279504616382 | Tapered | point load | Low | Short | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1228 | 106.17100002733649 |
152 | Aluminum | 199.83468375664552 | 0.3201972263154291 | 3600.6859324170505 | 551.4422632033628 | 90.21923073666188 | 5548.178019648359 | -47.38878647519978 | 133278.9646866758 | 39 | 27.014660007133294 | 60.866659789775156 | 10.560645886031729 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1633 | 141.72752839006483 |
153 | Titanium | 63.346614579642875 | 0.30306911546304 | 2362.8807754211434 | 1415.9203545052771 | 80.5816444772247 | 17351.474946353977 | -40.12230196353694 | 127459.85686627339 | 24 | 40.98467167944583 | 38.050428347155844 | 7.273395981229688 | Rectangular | uniform | High | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 709 | 146.03254076967374 |
154 | Aluminum | 99.03814614207573 | 0.32342099098643534 | 2375.1714757871277 | 820.7548287633477 | 72.90320398632147 | 5932.701076781486 | -54.6511846056833 | 111264.17108280904 | 38 | 48.02370098730475 | 57.00411064767947 | 12.520428253767896 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Medium | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1493 | 70.17661097124184 |
155 | Titanium | 75.40687540540495 | 0.3315691860783343 | 2497.8342587290663 | 957.1279266853898 | 88.70463096170494 | 17441.343051357162 | -51.20483888905378 | 163243.3348476423 | 21 | 53.414273690914 | 37.68268911481229 | 6.887629248729828 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Short | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1457 | 125.32675334813422 |
156 | Aluminum | 68.7646914946048 | 0.30777658491471355 | 3897.7519265548394 | 609.9990607893453 | 55.79652399971057 | 6645.951986020225 | -48.53260671660293 | 164627.0929374213 | 32 | 57.6371421486691 | 41.18433305603517 | 11.440008392983039 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Long | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 738 | 121.9161392642731 |
157 | Aluminum | 166.84737720236998 | 0.3283392199423162 | 4304.190176824549 | 620.4980214827424 | 98.27423279229362 | 16250.081921951974 | -40.81208789865232 | 149185.1709426367 | 35 | 25.768483008742148 | 48.06138969034268 | 5.228257496224748 | Cylindrical | distributed | High | Short | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1217 | 125.02294232646437 |
158 | Aluminum | 120.09837112725617 | 0.34461568525958663 | 3213.6706543037108 | 1175.6269928123868 | 80.4202971444144 | 14083.385127608668 | -54.26931548662968 | 131238.0656604902 | 33 | 21.578676961160138 | 36.80120918575558 | 10.841519321370292 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 831 | 64.45477053451731 |
159 | Aluminum | 56.69709945059187 | 0.3157407303502829 | 3826.410486284693 | 1080.9259051090617 | 58.83589412143627 | 6590.089848760536 | -41.41535206449319 | 187033.30865202827 | 23 | 43.91122127170813 | 51.11571041122241 | 7.989444813261352 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Long | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 901 | 63.51697588851752 |
160 | Aluminum | 156.82138309881876 | 0.3194607261329255 | 4085.234923360307 | 627.932083142415 | 81.56017962943649 | 6001.6215767873855 | -41.11837071458906 | 164988.11505586968 | 25 | 45.98213124519233 | 60.38292008526929 | 10.809049344061492 | Tapered | point load | High | Long | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 696 | 109.09169970740332 |
161 | Carbon Fiber | 187.11271147506574 | 0.32734695142171216 | 2643.417414356394 | 1308.1863690516734 | 90.79594817589891 | 18118.679212605603 | -42.69021349117605 | 170333.4083442096 | 36 | 52.86001186879699 | 41.90752235181173 | 11.133548285596133 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Short | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 970 | 104.04109691705183 |
162 | Titanium | 71.90895345209883 | 0.30731456673371693 | 2162.8354070282476 | 733.1004411361089 | 78.28734880971301 | 19543.093051009295 | -40.260691173904554 | 162301.12833883282 | 20 | 25.442045873054994 | 33.640062870680374 | 14.621281977080816 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Short | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1613 | 116.92311497595226 |
163 | Aluminum | 126.24244126027871 | 0.3288802504631441 | 4171.673435526482 | 980.478230335445 | 50.10844500858114 | 6793.918802491668 | -40.409615991806774 | 147705.58552853926 | 34 | 30.91367967753167 | 63.57714467766531 | 10.107418686608852 | Rectangular | uniform | Low | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 967 | 88.67737684798796 |
164 | Aluminum | 132.76809971399786 | 0.32189780582161676 | 3417.14160583138 | 289.5737330236487 | 83.56722642326741 | 14121.649937067752 | -56.12069347854465 | 191521.67829782344 | 24 | 48.34671037260384 | 64.10286253273657 | 7.508791361437304 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Short | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1877 | 59.83994986148069 |
165 | Carbon Fiber | 87.27337418029798 | 0.3058619078382297 | 4495.759088095127 | 1276.6913647750052 | 62.477724176645246 | 6093.353110750253 | -47.909534456511075 | 172851.74463450734 | 24 | 49.354744194186964 | 32.068674111671 | 11.7714425156925 | Cylindrical | distributed | High | Long | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1101 | 112.9440876077484 |
166 | Titanium | 116.9414619999563 | 0.33933657389100114 | 2423.07131646441 | 1343.6407368128528 | 91.04009236910004 | 11240.295163927125 | -49.4982234096901 | 180430.24725062805 | 24 | 38.69732246117138 | 30.668971993706606 | 8.25551629521799 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Long | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1067 | 88.93385095457998 |
167 | Aluminum | 199.6874303498191 | 0.3047197704719732 | 4424.727677117145 | 558.644999159548 | 95.58079668543044 | 7914.392919918006 | -59.17744253906887 | 135754.78216345742 | 37 | 45.51256588734137 | 34.419196059500926 | 11.230571539488661 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Short | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 924 | 132.38295848454538 |
168 | Carbon Fiber | 75.51484945659993 | 0.33405857566920594 | 3363.1487120786687 | 1194.0493461586047 | 56.330741869416094 | 6045.464723982278 | -53.59800941435614 | 147713.74795957396 | 24 | 34.603685279744354 | 66.9263574944235 | 8.986823689904723 | Cylindrical | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1881 | 82.44187083874371 |
169 | Aluminum | 94.56556089203033 | 0.32471489572568857 | 1584.5843655427811 | 331.82785276571803 | 59.22638425632325 | 6882.740038603013 | -50.04815261162904 | 187062.10894017783 | 37 | 21.855638741193207 | 45.08907489943889 | 10.654477149270479 | Cylindrical | distributed | Low | Short | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 660 | 142.44977118998773 |
170 | Titanium | 67.56157998854103 | 0.30783795527593555 | 1836.821865576465 | 877.5766596023909 | 56.6066820501142 | 6903.689512086867 | -53.7507415039341 | 158602.44878113928 | 24 | 26.612918205950965 | 65.04635680736085 | 12.977760179877997 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Long | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1203 | 70.64000738974406 |
171 | Titanium | 125.07938576615493 | 0.32189147886041664 | 2782.8714251932015 | 718.9670851660708 | 66.65101514102729 | 15294.060891879028 | -51.23347730450811 | 144137.30534534185 | 26 | 42.700097820602636 | 55.98060292223079 | 14.705272243484217 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Medium | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 725 | 62.27031892039555 |
172 | Titanium | 171.80122164360668 | 0.3331430707404452 | 2251.918018777694 | 514.4999745149837 | 99.60466799554584 | 11283.724755384825 | -56.66569701916052 | 154999.755319985 | 38 | 30.57953333704328 | 67.72994242837936 | 12.229155159854734 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Short | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1032 | 134.07035448382464 |
173 | Carbon Fiber | 138.96799913988195 | 0.34049735313848034 | 2426.0133803637464 | 1118.382882280015 | 92.57949161144754 | 10483.325884279644 | -40.03928514984504 | 127953.53212084374 | 23 | 46.959535447461285 | 49.84862549141527 | 10.171385333543206 | Tapered | point load | Moderate | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1115 | 51.89795087302753 |
174 | Titanium | 170.82449016726224 | 0.31942975170320026 | 3193.2421121115203 | 721.1988787181929 | 79.81817304673737 | 16097.863768073987 | -50.58823880556335 | 184786.23605019 | 33 | 24.569823534818287 | 59.82052256629467 | 8.35684247123519 | Tapered | distributed | High | Long | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1428 | 119.59362289246151 |
175 | Titanium | 93.72792302224357 | 0.3396116047649838 | 3275.5856375930666 | 412.69901706851135 | 60.26073064232294 | 14552.069800588883 | -43.26346955265798 | 182321.9884871071 | 36 | 52.05321058489518 | 47.352347342645345 | 10.791958622189856 | Tapered | point load | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 620 | 132.8946773365208 |
176 | Titanium | 128.338591606834 | 0.318390204537693 | 4156.482730017622 | 733.4835579355744 | 92.0218058131863 | 19935.24077476948 | -56.850923338378564 | 192002.143145962 | 38 | 45.89018799666829 | 66.46359221326031 | 14.152896210103163 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1148 | 132.33449945744422 |
177 | Aluminum | 73.8090149565966 | 0.3408177430826213 | 2448.5769128868724 | 1396.0152771077885 | 64.95695257697055 | 6579.9292426561415 | -59.621153861919844 | 158525.7366886848 | 25 | 23.997234466418927 | 47.124959238216064 | 14.003469289536568 | Rectangular | uniform | Low | Short | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 626 | 139.9244882646708 |
178 | Titanium | 73.32930465871681 | 0.34272745401880583 | 2534.934963035566 | 490.3231064566148 | 50.75393812627439 | 5778.830183082483 | -50.97413969615735 | 194582.21302045288 | 37 | 55.060416445991535 | 42.87058833575507 | 6.5783400656322275 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1056 | 64.88532297441647 |
179 | Titanium | 180.09620133045038 | 0.3243864678621922 | 2369.803768005643 | 889.3929429389649 | 54.03987066866878 | 13138.41567489173 | -52.05198449209837 | 103293.43451524385 | 32 | 38.81194007351337 | 32.069989399260486 | 6.648687829011585 | Cylindrical | distributed | Low | Medium | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 712 | 68.51025671837998 |
180 | Titanium | 101.07948481019235 | 0.33960313788297314 | 1889.8579051754625 | 1124.2988306453503 | 62.85349978189063 | 12309.01725714908 | -45.96427553301792 | 105879.52201363584 | 39 | 25.72064433241934 | 49.41769584481503 | 5.5465256548168504 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Medium | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1283 | 137.07259263296592 |
181 | Titanium | 109.19277192955673 | 0.32794549413266527 | 3187.2397495107853 | 293.65021239896515 | 86.9663194111391 | 13603.171726785527 | -45.672039740679665 | 128067.73578506942 | 25 | 23.567439045494115 | 54.148813489052024 | 13.120443138632027 | Cylindrical | distributed | Low | Long | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 523 | 113.42455169039488 |
182 | Carbon Fiber | 152.6696023504366 | 0.32952897873152875 | 2708.4365867001634 | 737.8015144790563 | 89.89940486560965 | 17775.09829661627 | -47.309929390925745 | 141917.39504487993 | 31 | 58.0582076477414 | 33.70070914398852 | 13.023187220065957 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 914 | 58.620883204954865 |
183 | Carbon Fiber | 112.00881959133545 | 0.31865886549879124 | 2755.436104319301 | 827.4034301694264 | 89.74930422558322 | 14838.05760832567 | -45.552019841846985 | 112338.63643995016 | 33 | 53.93675126274105 | 42.137620790526654 | 9.703516423209647 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Medium | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1197 | 92.89287075409526 |
184 | Carbon Fiber | 60.70789009281995 | 0.31567797098301037 | 3374.3329592433865 | 1333.3458865405053 | 64.96536079423925 | 13371.680365898603 | -49.542903560932444 | 132120.00267518786 | 38 | 55.64041576527538 | 61.11139741954567 | 14.891479885329671 | Cylindrical | uniform | High | Long | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1056 | 52.03076503170191 |
185 | Carbon Fiber | 152.78095182641238 | 0.3435710779182959 | 3245.7268453799197 | 330.6063540016541 | 83.98137964973716 | 17329.41791403921 | -48.83775942445844 | 167410.03330741858 | 39 | 54.5044189573799 | 31.28338014760349 | 12.213018309392393 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Medium | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 548 | 85.3271833848091 |
186 | Titanium | 71.82378604002112 | 0.3229463423087163 | 4262.4569636484375 | 751.3346948437769 | 74.09468183540808 | 6359.634529770067 | -52.93897848034652 | 113917.69690990448 | 39 | 26.355100760186616 | 36.62370911418838 | 5.779340000642436 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Short | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 892 | 79.46087045377946 |
187 | Titanium | 112.88745859776303 | 0.3380030989324535 | 2353.831236769237 | 609.6598578681815 | 87.84470151574206 | 17566.83131929546 | -56.98103002033637 | 190363.484531281 | 33 | 22.162191679365996 | 59.27997176763812 | 13.54248522244884 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1212 | 124.75508064914825 |
188 | Carbon Fiber | 67.78219734186854 | 0.33265422145285306 | 2725.360533071691 | 1205.3204072061385 | 66.84198968265436 | 10805.422987986924 | -52.72093138532442 | 187830.11061932036 | 24 | 44.96523857887968 | 68.68944500566197 | 12.849360176457019 | Cylindrical | distributed | High | Long | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1754 | 59.38920611494613 |
189 | Aluminum | 199.78606273674143 | 0.307865367238671 | 4304.972831494888 | 564.5985806335037 | 54.5733096092584 | 15720.149500251373 | -58.189778883064335 | 132944.42555412892 | 20 | 41.87944215333776 | 68.82410015827699 | 8.7020863196409 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Long | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1674 | 56.20041624840617 |
190 | Titanium | 99.9159121694745 | 0.3215679473316001 | 3104.8504860547678 | 1404.2009528252047 | 99.53492609965339 | 16797.347420211536 | -58.58934051995491 | 109472.15555236513 | 34 | 43.1196462990673 | 50.650836421485664 | 11.05158755097041 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Short | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1563 | 79.19727407478022 |
191 | Aluminum | 99.85072406041925 | 0.33694346622334626 | 3488.9115457916373 | 1081.2967351827815 | 59.55445634592409 | 5113.454695968275 | -58.713687019179254 | 186970.55663227077 | 22 | 24.94991352248734 | 43.050441430124195 | 9.710147732066435 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Long | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 1013 | 100.21775025214265 |
192 | Titanium | 133.45966673826945 | 0.32753318933012904 | 4116.376820774793 | 1428.4627149310197 | 86.36285149858058 | 10185.161725647138 | -41.74214783029139 | 199838.63734669943 | 34 | 37.380486593526655 | 35.380110658370796 | 10.303594291097014 | Cylindrical | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 739 | 105.61200759744418 |
193 | Titanium | 126.50016901527833 | 0.3425330024107249 | 3674.7584963395907 | 664.9957792545542 | 84.42230576682806 | 9402.140775464159 | -53.64645590379666 | 187629.0472539254 | 20 | 30.066633996365496 | 57.798188607419746 | 9.566723001663053 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Short | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1839 | 52.97313133525133 |
194 | Carbon Fiber | 158.20249699278673 | 0.32260635061828874 | 3752.2161815070735 | 279.48367123112206 | 76.33619428727037 | 8881.060893684102 | -58.55166580633603 | 129150.50343372603 | 27 | 54.796301529901875 | 62.74881032998602 | 13.418383768935735 | Tapered | uniform | Low | Short | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1825 | 144.4092085062881 |
195 | Titanium | 168.18628662563543 | 0.3230392300140324 | 4118.8404631486155 | 1196.787065368414 | 52.197071639575675 | 8486.47982359324 | -49.61997957460107 | 146707.4214953051 | 31 | 32.5203199380889 | 61.10291371285684 | 12.014884030961241 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Short | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 896 | 131.7161089292363 |
196 | Carbon Fiber | 93.47735172074647 | 0.3276819676144798 | 2461.4502324587656 | 893.1608284010018 | 88.67322484997868 | 6318.7151113607615 | -45.27239417126991 | 166276.46674818557 | 28 | 59.700470731936086 | 44.35268177850554 | 11.628575506756757 | Tapered | point load | Low | Long | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1409 | 113.61113754907214 |
197 | Titanium | 78.74767208214891 | 0.3393160164635287 | 2057.271009239906 | 1099.9073857258832 | 80.92414713704787 | 10019.07631869839 | -54.69440571537877 | 196017.24096054427 | 39 | 49.971522523709055 | 42.47769655220852 | 13.832703481352116 | Tapered | distributed | High | Long | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 672 | 75.75295895588889 |
198 | Aluminum | 137.3156664647344 | 0.3167303831072694 | 2273.51898115326 | 764.4424718713115 | 74.55181572014045 | 11358.504149523967 | -46.34248615756951 | 186888.2786083053 | 34 | 24.332813734912648 | 66.46489766008504 | 14.524090817490867 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Long | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1601 | 131.29518574000878 |
199 | Carbon Fiber | 130.48208971511093 | 0.33876012064799194 | 2768.2841982761684 | 1419.6990087330503 | 69.42598813221026 | 19416.25121338723 | -58.53002632646023 | 157355.11169621354 | 39 | 24.78932552302384 | 48.4089098999 | 11.793058438855784 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Short | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1221 | 134.3131854824422 |
200 | Titanium | 63.324962872687195 | 0.3080869092058525 | 3061.478556553598 | 871.2877922323855 | 71.06368516485479 | 8113.543617345882 | -50.274422033708845 | 140441.7745384745 | 20 | 51.47575226315695 | 31.211102177975167 | 12.559639350984689 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Long | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 699 | 135.73738575527426 |
201 | Titanium | 123.53565721862158 | 0.3019454773671641 | 2092.8653620474424 | 1071.551350909288 | 97.66763776298635 | 9769.9545023014 | -57.71260017205171 | 197133.8444764602 | 27 | 26.601907639912675 | 50.83135124738388 | 10.083783780990393 | Tapered | point load | High | Medium | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 895 | 149.83364146455503 |
202 | Carbon Fiber | 109.4490154547812 | 0.3493304450478336 | 3615.6779026183744 | 1162.3849487235677 | 84.09729086203858 | 14541.30925567411 | -48.164918890181845 | 138151.10251520772 | 34 | 42.52848903553894 | 57.38284362095126 | 8.237433673721114 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Medium | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 615 | 79.10062304982083 |
203 | Titanium | 187.28303417858402 | 0.3268088480006997 | 2480.3234434401056 | 701.8223404543419 | 78.63575099523484 | 6921.19655520528 | -40.97457228204692 | 151900.34389142768 | 33 | 31.157930875928365 | 42.72094795523928 | 12.599270883937432 | Cylindrical | distributed | Low | Long | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1610 | 72.13513294682767 |
204 | Carbon Fiber | 117.9492393494834 | 0.30890008719063605 | 3543.270095672942 | 711.4926785112391 | 60.466462990134275 | 8052.351570900372 | -58.41390438974412 | 179659.30099874543 | 38 | 30.458436101970623 | 35.14032903773569 | 5.17665603182364 | Rectangular | uniform | High | Medium | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1961 | 132.48423534114286 |
205 | Titanium | 161.3299132526702 | 0.3299691505131516 | 1914.4833836107175 | 1124.9501831359403 | 70.74377781428917 | 18759.32532046469 | -43.09644160936145 | 169385.61950749977 | 28 | 25.778546972591954 | 65.33356446956168 | 14.8800238827295 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Medium | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1179 | 141.4768127000948 |
206 | Carbon Fiber | 131.53722696393785 | 0.3210177578287089 | 4351.720576933076 | 830.9522874371552 | 52.48215382448273 | 11997.669731326761 | -44.70364888805722 | 160890.99338429153 | 26 | 21.703534389184753 | 30.929704958938004 | 7.957677732156462 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Short | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1095 | 132.57037458431398 |
207 | Titanium | 115.5421836442394 | 0.32389907583998245 | 2842.3475771895073 | 860.8376832820627 | 93.80644042712058 | 9151.577712295943 | -48.36929942011754 | 174367.47435508907 | 22 | 49.04126664299555 | 65.01051880617047 | 11.029100023969796 | Rectangular | uniform | High | Short | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1857 | 148.94514534036836 |
208 | Carbon Fiber | 107.37747891979318 | 0.30579121410987914 | 3883.9844093515403 | 1424.663755277445 | 74.80393350691968 | 11959.579313290447 | -41.27448348614631 | 139227.46634058078 | 21 | 22.20427859058068 | 45.34828971514548 | 10.671933220076628 | Rectangular | point load | High | Medium | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 946 | 148.57945163008623 |
209 | Carbon Fiber | 144.79355569751556 | 0.30401440197199087 | 3352.744181713453 | 510.1914441574008 | 82.2269918971399 | 14253.075194501742 | -45.18778171701921 | 143006.45903088132 | 36 | 39.36219953244666 | 66.26897863350095 | 8.566996455448294 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1305 | 100.87720026479181 |
210 | Titanium | 84.53087473684803 | 0.3162160863721583 | 3534.2925631675453 | 374.17163832267056 | 51.689503598965715 | 7543.510330141304 | -52.02872614226409 | 180752.53448797038 | 24 | 21.3608915610936 | 30.378353085973057 | 10.34132843272321 | Cylindrical | uniform | High | Long | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1133 | 117.16748745373539 |
211 | Carbon Fiber | 168.65728986466507 | 0.33300308399234574 | 3444.1420863367002 | 1064.475101438682 | 88.72069727520778 | 15797.595304615263 | -56.16920982151109 | 106122.18622900116 | 39 | 29.17662268818939 | 35.91719475288422 | 12.912029831038916 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Medium | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1932 | 103.06570831206002 |
212 | Titanium | 183.501113634111 | 0.3425786303028783 | 1779.977470346558 | 591.0588368715744 | 63.81845628666689 | 15416.903081321543 | -49.057924891994816 | 126681.35598185097 | 31 | 28.788747003501072 | 41.149848591568826 | 9.053157559123933 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1828 | 129.26829528750548 |
213 | Aluminum | 161.17448530636005 | 0.3231393900637663 | 3963.8079137082327 | 811.3205380558993 | 62.87296068221107 | 19126.645016357095 | -50.925493922973395 | 190515.40622172243 | 28 | 48.266917712098106 | 69.38449898796816 | 11.113015503806395 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 914 | 142.24981809497183 |
214 | Carbon Fiber | 58.031266833012474 | 0.30400445670195025 | 2017.2896486078218 | 978.2253625036751 | 64.2730276828996 | 19088.780933865164 | -57.798662948257224 | 143405.54017249358 | 24 | 28.01505766878925 | 58.10790660179279 | 13.596178637277045 | Tapered | point load | High | Short | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1931 | 79.87429925535136 |
215 | Titanium | 136.37570297212676 | 0.33334205223689 | 1550.048780843938 | 559.783649359762 | 91.40958115345033 | 7915.29748861066 | -47.457077299388146 | 146187.3548008253 | 36 | 20.624112778864557 | 39.561022351842695 | 6.343586350155961 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Long | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1138 | 97.73123836389028 |
216 | Carbon Fiber | 152.73405190577824 | 0.30926024316365874 | 2761.1131143090333 | 1333.476356567212 | 69.68815281390472 | 5520.245690458759 | -57.58023072754013 | 101602.67980436113 | 33 | 50.678436730889175 | 68.28455266234405 | 7.558440556547277 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1200 | 110.09101922559063 |
217 | Carbon Fiber | 57.65181232405935 | 0.3396311005140293 | 2084.8499154694873 | 796.3040907029854 | 52.815287554060184 | 13338.838661242955 | -55.709090315430224 | 117838.79386039113 | 30 | 45.97437673837672 | 35.739866563601694 | 13.714408959552953 | Cylindrical | distributed | Moderate | Long | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1500 | 145.43479233206568 |
218 | Aluminum | 138.00936462311864 | 0.34008559990155973 | 2180.076257600897 | 412.8283858301651 | 86.67372114471809 | 18081.527465381667 | -51.36536544876153 | 116965.26840437623 | 24 | 37.22172771198903 | 32.056144710352235 | 12.96176874333899 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 1320 | 141.9082454648015 |
219 | Titanium | 196.84594476126284 | 0.30850845667844773 | 2175.3043891890643 | 521.8084513237167 | 97.61949349987913 | 9391.424635768917 | -44.53569017196954 | 111947.8596010432 | 23 | 29.74796638040003 | 34.02639278313511 | 9.337394759048873 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Medium | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1028 | 90.02667642409997 |
220 | Carbon Fiber | 125.00981945347718 | 0.3240182530588267 | 2232.7246963421417 | 1275.7195811371134 | 74.35490058460826 | 16228.05210583642 | -52.26426132990494 | 139790.1601827328 | 29 | 26.48347289088477 | 43.63705672286863 | 7.567715406697869 | Tapered | distributed | High | Short | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1005 | 53.295603308285756 |
221 | Aluminum | 125.4708165272372 | 0.31409741458499807 | 3142.899157908142 | 484.0823770068456 | 92.63091616559348 | 6712.079144696568 | -47.57403797580669 | 173312.72842813522 | 23 | 28.588487616308527 | 42.35195672191338 | 6.269652526124117 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Medium | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1877 | 64.63359850697437 |
222 | Titanium | 187.38252838993355 | 0.31278577404373176 | 4154.004764908057 | 1279.0301528283187 | 69.78222204073813 | 8369.025762996407 | -45.56440913091964 | 124798.41086824168 | 34 | 39.21407025992183 | 53.29858906288534 | 9.957279404793724 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Short | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 787 | 54.69873674920136 |
223 | Aluminum | 198.97573082046426 | 0.31611805152376743 | 4249.546997931168 | 561.4347049373589 | 78.98151686062941 | 12759.169213647192 | -49.63077723689678 | 122600.18159426015 | 39 | 42.69543078562213 | 63.5321284920028 | 5.13882024963404 | Rectangular | uniform | Low | Long | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 780 | 109.48976221438011 |
224 | Carbon Fiber | 67.3327214126077 | 0.31329992398170314 | 3980.754750235748 | 1055.5266295727563 | 98.64527239749165 | 19671.280386867606 | -40.575220575982776 | 165555.1606510082 | 28 | 44.67368688077056 | 41.33831710966791 | 6.507958579841045 | Cylindrical | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 860 | 129.59724070261154 |
225 | Titanium | 153.44339182596354 | 0.33328375237813057 | 4376.079652658282 | 594.4456593943303 | 56.27998056276017 | 19213.456966310776 | -51.60061157221861 | 144812.75737787058 | 32 | 53.32819939646124 | 48.75672192337582 | 9.788017251789842 | Tapered | distributed | High | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1396 | 58.694753247750796 |
226 | Carbon Fiber | 161.7449553000091 | 0.3023294424864961 | 1857.4660804630394 | 1089.283797175654 | 52.88366879007044 | 9748.459592535786 | -50.329528080283026 | 140712.49395419424 | 36 | 28.02765592006115 | 43.38852961774215 | 8.301754947348403 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Long | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1921 | 138.4107694682034 |
227 | Aluminum | 183.449068679844 | 0.3474382841617692 | 3511.9630590409315 | 1037.041969635995 | 70.90816430852627 | 16558.04577283501 | -43.065584496641875 | 103447.10545876047 | 36 | 43.3099662741761 | 48.39397825911057 | 6.526074212954347 | Tapered | point load | Low | Short | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1897 | 110.43117133437039 |
228 | Aluminum | 84.34175298014374 | 0.32923496098639327 | 2937.631457719022 | 747.8873337860011 | 82.0672914524597 | 10459.033005382134 | -58.861280769856 | 197460.25065263844 | 35 | 39.371991815316946 | 55.91369817694962 | 12.533248237095753 | Rectangular | point load | High | Long | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1844 | 53.83283357820259 |
229 | Aluminum | 67.42242563333039 | 0.3198241480371565 | 4034.4540017486343 | 865.8454321190122 | 89.89782600440333 | 18327.72732919913 | -45.960759413066256 | 127743.9501795964 | 24 | 46.69028937165877 | 64.36473587601357 | 8.269387610657912 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Long | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1292 | 130.4977015541189 |
230 | Aluminum | 53.428797742534876 | 0.30701977954630527 | 3880.9260094917463 | 1427.5053449420695 | 86.58333805315425 | 19841.77115868535 | -40.78009536430089 | 159551.2177648068 | 24 | 36.35101481033976 | 57.71187519204943 | 13.537845454417953 | Tapered | distributed | Low | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 764 | 69.11169350391867 |
231 | Carbon Fiber | 57.085239062242955 | 0.31110295608930855 | 2351.341950180716 | 1120.558298685262 | 58.760346049359875 | 14645.49745718864 | -54.566123079950394 | 167206.28603439394 | 38 | 41.92399528837048 | 38.16433772984278 | 10.349883951908946 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Medium | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1897 | 114.52518324912403 |
232 | Carbon Fiber | 168.19615939315727 | 0.3263770892550651 | 3792.8163960174447 | 1364.2760740255196 | 86.54518119532469 | 16342.860787792799 | -52.85236979846153 | 106835.90302989399 | 38 | 32.25214762338884 | 39.08357113573517 | 10.03724920221303 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Short | Excellent | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1080 | 127.31209225597671 |
233 | Carbon Fiber | 50.1475199417925 | 0.3224325835745488 | 2168.9859015896436 | 1493.0549273647625 | 91.96471326354984 | 17054.683588562442 | -41.225334562671016 | 150129.63820626203 | 22 | 55.90437881833589 | 59.60274854453128 | 6.3050341682685005 | Tapered | uniform | High | Short | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 884 | 56.96457478298099 |
234 | Aluminum | 159.07730124038275 | 0.34799394665493916 | 3297.2093547244895 | 282.1359945803931 | 69.78894226805491 | 17758.767533921025 | -56.7120251199934 | 111919.5932774671 | 39 | 57.805949133021414 | 43.54369710480097 | 14.4217296994304 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Long | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1490 | 71.35566842173844 |
235 | Titanium | 128.34881345740627 | 0.3387625696834526 | 3134.1917049602225 | 668.0202692030247 | 69.79289577307985 | 16752.713305694906 | -48.92199507477562 | 160168.28905275164 | 26 | 53.05368787381495 | 60.16018178155578 | 12.076046186049634 | Tapered | uniform | High | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1730 | 90.34207811742473 |
236 | Aluminum | 129.4176254705561 | 0.3262390016305974 | 3549.57740622188 | 615.3025537577353 | 79.07169020894653 | 11849.012576972262 | -42.95362668552802 | 163034.67494548205 | 31 | 27.683376874307477 | 64.08543908539716 | 6.2561395983859915 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Medium | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1284 | 63.11740273130661 |
237 | Carbon Fiber | 60.806337298961296 | 0.3230222960495691 | 3321.2724277481525 | 801.9434206773415 | 90.766773055349 | 7257.273913628722 | -40.52741253068015 | 119170.99041870018 | 30 | 37.4617433267726 | 53.475696515026364 | 5.007289818643935 | Tapered | uniform | High | Short | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1096 | 141.90390813477325 |
238 | Carbon Fiber | 191.8542837494378 | 0.3037113248683276 | 1586.7272265085812 | 1313.9306437749235 | 78.21852152618891 | 18824.23209280477 | -58.52091695519492 | 122776.87365120626 | 38 | 51.36011880765493 | 48.28008969630485 | 10.079738727492192 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Medium | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1053 | 148.3250831379027 |
239 | Titanium | 159.14293007922234 | 0.32610440831699034 | 3163.516545861131 | 921.0157911989576 | 78.8888050650946 | 13399.177494955497 | -43.7081038131101 | 197546.09556894522 | 35 | 58.75202805455484 | 34.35722913538366 | 13.546434072556297 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1365 | 80.38110095341474 |
240 | Aluminum | 95.50765953161259 | 0.3002257803282272 | 3158.6256019542134 | 1490.5235370651883 | 76.01797882167446 | 17631.090753943892 | -52.76475754892414 | 115894.11274221505 | 38 | 49.163006425808234 | 40.86634408985985 | 8.992884408791785 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Short | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1102 | 71.98895383216399 |
241 | Carbon Fiber | 177.08228446053897 | 0.3372549244206147 | 3393.5636323503795 | 415.0516391584613 | 67.89140120394781 | 7338.27562295662 | -56.18675938413862 | 141387.1961985939 | 30 | 33.88594494249489 | 68.38598707832885 | 6.024580189637602 | Cylindrical | uniform | High | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1970 | 78.6215810565587 |
242 | Carbon Fiber | 93.27030406015186 | 0.31787050045695514 | 4468.365747528785 | 1382.5984018279678 | 90.93766608470104 | 18108.68756569468 | -48.51977821348551 | 121354.52788959286 | 28 | 41.702269196271274 | 66.06573358244032 | 5.703669707507533 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Short | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1583 | 78.81348546354856 |
243 | Carbon Fiber | 103.44986977859799 | 0.3015192609639968 | 1624.7948489505502 | 957.9323653550438 | 98.60162522179414 | 12263.574150762619 | -44.48251578282595 | 125600.48754599207 | 20 | 21.906181605603457 | 53.54398218465961 | 8.923569902670542 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Short | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1567 | 68.41598451723618 |
244 | Aluminum | 59.85024692881366 | 0.33035966803109845 | 1926.1425119023147 | 1039.7650001949914 | 76.46262730149351 | 14858.91491755473 | -52.122000906018826 | 195524.92918411846 | 22 | 32.70098726354604 | 41.20930560944943 | 10.20891531546451 | Rectangular | distributed | Moderate | Short | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 616 | 119.81058315170866 |
245 | Aluminum | 145.10220223203737 | 0.32083344923480306 | 2466.1745404384546 | 1458.3643486495646 | 92.93416096366246 | 16512.885729684836 | -46.97636482464479 | 194996.1770537466 | 25 | 24.3946198251297 | 33.39827001545552 | 12.215211244370117 | Rectangular | point load | High | Long | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1504 | 79.98148748392312 |
246 | Aluminum | 156.23663628672296 | 0.31383419535100976 | 1611.0951453140658 | 772.5830581098461 | 84.91059517603884 | 8657.163121623667 | -54.33301737449769 | 185253.6328148537 | 38 | 29.595385592804387 | 52.85203823643974 | 12.23396142686233 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Short | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 933 | 65.54861969838592 |
247 | Aluminum | 129.40441584207443 | 0.3113574899189524 | 2983.299087638119 | 286.113113217805 | 55.93064049664957 | 14852.302540288127 | -42.52506245084881 | 151435.9020039608 | 34 | 25.467522803867517 | 47.405947027879506 | 11.690922072779568 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Short | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1524 | 128.88023033746975 |
248 | Carbon Fiber | 159.74559288388912 | 0.3102209106189198 | 2875.944494102293 | 604.2988642726604 | 70.68488412680576 | 8044.280517760523 | -53.19658930819816 | 137196.8254794872 | 33 | 57.72686548143357 | 50.27300046378633 | 10.866539282225778 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Long | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 954 | 96.86733920125826 |
249 | Aluminum | 155.8393301315951 | 0.3426252457818588 | 1937.1872841391591 | 512.5767590499013 | 52.291383506519786 | 19266.927247512023 | -50.190590906917514 | 177493.24021970894 | 30 | 42.193561547597 | 68.24995426694744 | 13.714735079476572 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Short | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1151 | 122.65855766786242 |
250 | Titanium | 124.38390592380034 | 0.3298943473320918 | 2529.5597341716802 | 718.5950718562467 | 55.69914726794903 | 5884.309861069101 | -43.57902714619591 | 118356.34720418457 | 24 | 24.917482502412835 | 62.048482304312664 | 5.7246230685096275 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Long | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1569 | 94.06164767783511 |
251 | Carbon Fiber | 147.06351138935955 | 0.31371683449892473 | 1586.6715999425744 | 747.9921607993817 | 94.49979950160741 | 19655.50934295629 | -41.63211436747248 | 125838.02920841033 | 31 | 57.055513803360924 | 49.42016034129139 | 9.031507981102704 | Rectangular | point load | Low | Medium | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1340 | 103.58042100009911 |
252 | Carbon Fiber | 138.05967626418652 | 0.3168444668841396 | 3573.185229158968 | 1358.6782701354248 | 91.93515798661696 | 10740.562349915166 | -40.52579012793008 | 191134.4733947721 | 31 | 34.978602554505926 | 65.32691887127287 | 5.002665120391389 | Tapered | point load | Low | Medium | Excellent | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1666 | 132.20683382549674 |
253 | Carbon Fiber | 104.09492941174557 | 0.3381619739888985 | 2555.484186857165 | 1421.3921046449352 | 52.24277639629873 | 14297.323214101865 | -56.965944362029994 | 102036.38431816829 | 30 | 20.730539262197368 | 55.559594615666654 | 9.439345941532457 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Long | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1983 | 108.11524561951418 |
254 | Aluminum | 171.70401126092554 | 0.3377089240480896 | 3751.192228966798 | 943.999928534063 | 80.31303028002746 | 6697.475397037162 | -42.792750960092874 | 127418.52743523614 | 31 | 51.26189900470396 | 36.125874271187385 | 13.533339954964113 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Short | Poor | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 879 | 84.48499277895189 |
255 | Titanium | 60.484640668248126 | 0.32574846579810257 | 1793.997006732732 | 335.2350290226964 | 60.156575490146906 | 5085.762895380582 | -41.626859155023695 | 164442.33638856414 | 34 | 48.132985728583705 | 44.22281060226674 | 10.68695838672264 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 680 | 102.89897110836881 |
256 | Aluminum | 91.88923194895838 | 0.33506809257701897 | 4171.373814819603 | 731.3437573186568 | 59.099347411554064 | 7008.140891272159 | -43.601039117699905 | 189945.493456338 | 32 | 38.85912669665809 | 69.58975536684518 | 6.508198998912061 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 622 | 74.27080950415265 |
257 | Titanium | 198.51241145775035 | 0.32572130001328586 | 4005.206019704468 | 691.9507988005614 | 61.41226833287119 | 14060.467167154186 | -49.971827159526924 | 173869.65341240546 | 26 | 44.89180944204042 | 40.27420863176589 | 6.7720054985989195 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Medium | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1096 | 52.31034389266972 |
258 | Titanium | 166.39684387245256 | 0.3461118037885186 | 2035.1298568926777 | 1463.516946166312 | 50.647692267905896 | 13087.61878333434 | -59.62180467301834 | 199589.4115631007 | 39 | 28.102079491684965 | 31.398487482070546 | 11.734603870975022 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Short | Poor | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1572 | 72.85065873217532 |
259 | Carbon Fiber | 151.44739672956135 | 0.31306804156299434 | 2647.662272489538 | 312.3242890680026 | 75.50388560144992 | 7783.912358218977 | -44.92102965073815 | 139328.78670744144 | 37 | 34.81550656625869 | 61.50889592633849 | 9.599565586502468 | Tapered | distributed | High | Medium | Excellent | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 575 | 144.744777789402 |
260 | Titanium | 168.29118621672035 | 0.3357715357189974 | 3710.271445655975 | 979.2504648681735 | 57.337411236785925 | 5350.723601828506 | -59.137729284974874 | 112531.1630605543 | 32 | 23.941216057740103 | 51.646469681532295 | 14.938447247403403 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Short | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1564 | 55.5217890109575 |
261 | Aluminum | 141.56360490479676 | 0.33796379859101244 | 3442.4633663124723 | 482.4565544720325 | 92.00604567118044 | 9516.56698078591 | -59.531832084291 | 104190.16758434002 | 36 | 38.4470505546949 | 49.32498158982234 | 13.50327961146064 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 809 | 135.9400441070838 |
262 | Aluminum | 156.14665339101856 | 0.3448177532374029 | 2273.6373521717687 | 265.4341464147885 | 64.8965611311593 | 17070.264198277648 | -54.12140128817527 | 180546.0655689793 | 29 | 59.25602198893366 | 47.72023068179749 | 6.7554112877938435 | Rectangular | uniform | Low | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 1830 | 109.01889951046488 |
263 | Aluminum | 186.35219262122487 | 0.3326552752850483 | 4258.772765693722 | 968.1218134331315 | 74.49107352556676 | 7290.61487077061 | -44.37110429385557 | 100171.58928205323 | 28 | 47.08281242102227 | 60.163608010835155 | 14.28696523524599 | Cylindrical | point load | High | Medium | Good | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1567 | 95.96096866912072 |
264 | Titanium | 77.32531776454842 | 0.30786647184051247 | 1659.784082054094 | 905.0046011050001 | 62.915780464455025 | 14400.176350510319 | -49.07015680790664 | 125679.4516497108 | 24 | 36.48200962091373 | 66.02444616604825 | 13.966945573607797 | Cylindrical | distributed | High | Medium | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1309 | 140.66903311095058 |
265 | Aluminum | 60.049487142818236 | 0.3407841888228831 | 2760.8560586518524 | 300.30327455345457 | 96.33097058314851 | 17257.44453323435 | -56.41382135140423 | 185533.90661767777 | 30 | 40.852017259610236 | 35.19735907219575 | 13.980378160188657 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Medium | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1864 | 104.92854012037427 |
266 | Carbon Fiber | 151.9538216823329 | 0.3221474246707368 | 1702.4318829468336 | 541.3965007010958 | 66.00587638353169 | 7110.035334122142 | -53.68156452713198 | 170178.52731901256 | 37 | 39.87547984350953 | 49.07124484433884 | 11.394304922861073 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Long | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 851 | 120.8064944586448 |
267 | Aluminum | 173.67020380593257 | 0.31214139521525636 | 1781.7388727173634 | 1155.0187736253856 | 61.08114940514266 | 14878.982816786243 | -46.42044448454856 | 180427.31065770882 | 38 | 37.213652300161485 | 35.04161368786937 | 13.876900412908999 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Short | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 662 | 72.31556737626164 |
268 | Titanium | 83.99383252007797 | 0.33750142504332437 | 2723.2018500539207 | 797.6202186708347 | 51.22546878915388 | 11960.76331784355 | -53.5141056906284 | 182260.25088735457 | 29 | 32.13421848414275 | 62.25285294922725 | 11.42697179252313 | Cylindrical | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1528 | 119.85236375454163 |
269 | Titanium | 73.14818083777563 | 0.34394834746234393 | 1942.1599075163656 | 360.6833682370541 | 67.26979276142019 | 8481.514357385486 | -53.06464017549114 | 163179.81861464377 | 31 | 33.589081632999935 | 30.81779190194693 | 6.706978335349341 | Cylindrical | uniform | High | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1094 | 124.80323269144964 |
270 | Carbon Fiber | 136.26150284410426 | 0.30551953522520053 | 1979.9588155706736 | 1133.8869510505847 | 79.96223297446562 | 12626.428747250233 | -58.33193197077725 | 171662.4512674342 | 37 | 30.196883636635352 | 34.22237986067627 | 14.662507700548101 | Tapered | point load | High | Medium | Good | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 761 | 111.95483429623509 |
271 | Carbon Fiber | 186.7704624284862 | 0.30063675837991477 | 3965.99854697664 | 865.0213275297234 | 92.62167016322528 | 13699.36069643242 | -47.58973876916265 | 117880.21592821144 | 20 | 47.97737662692356 | 53.6907431456489 | 10.44824349716499 | Rectangular | point load | High | Long | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 1223 | 79.61694168958124 |
272 | Titanium | 99.82355031479588 | 0.30327758395320126 | 4008.920840766815 | 937.0666502781637 | 60.96550440822172 | 11454.44961618821 | -44.31827467032464 | 133690.293628842 | 39 | 40.19021328331874 | 30.646549984944457 | 12.472189443676902 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Medium | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1568 | 61.8883706863526 |
273 | Carbon Fiber | 188.00932199689447 | 0.3405895994284934 | 4089.732370172486 | 373.02697304690855 | 88.23066968513618 | 15740.313681368887 | -44.09372598500028 | 106962.69291739838 | 21 | 37.389433222826014 | 48.63921849536145 | 13.342877624081583 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Short | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1919 | 77.57765161557042 |
274 | Aluminum | 64.88289734563017 | 0.30624445767097386 | 1988.147642988144 | 335.46031263178975 | 65.80811928758766 | 13065.966031441094 | -49.9439966239004 | 163570.92543500435 | 32 | 48.206268580935664 | 35.486506124408315 | 12.91690494737031 | Tapered | point load | Low | Long | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 1424 | 103.47288828246892 |
275 | Aluminum | 134.09762093293463 | 0.3394207690433808 | 3482.5451440618344 | 372.5035392174285 | 67.10720219396096 | 13118.874797302262 | -56.15983471174473 | 150685.49449590297 | 37 | 45.805858258830256 | 54.653265551644864 | 9.455853114564926 | Cylindrical | distributed | High | Medium | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1250 | 66.78528324241148 |
276 | Carbon Fiber | 175.03107899478047 | 0.30866438424547804 | 3591.6155405575932 | 814.8028121815528 | 69.89617508264722 | 7386.706014574198 | -57.202844715305744 | 162535.89070983444 | 32 | 41.81140403395452 | 31.14356934949207 | 7.71432694676546 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Short | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 870 | 79.7849260433373 |
277 | Titanium | 89.13365846241868 | 0.34506135012491645 | 3132.411291988288 | 1152.3598212256977 | 72.30935128674004 | 6230.313598677851 | -54.8829335670404 | 163297.50020329354 | 39 | 31.962176900947043 | 31.45909523915328 | 8.998606967637816 | Rectangular | uniform | Moderate | Medium | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1186 | 62.6036435743822 |
278 | Titanium | 134.4840693580297 | 0.3251746495388523 | 3030.4785345729006 | 454.03231105276836 | 86.73007887714084 | 7721.772906245542 | -51.79719496099713 | 142104.6524330817 | 28 | 52.700400149760455 | 39.91951219468825 | 14.471794730760012 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Long | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1052 | 96.77927553880457 |
279 | Carbon Fiber | 188.96103015236105 | 0.30076536981279867 | 3709.1072489331127 | 859.2956916468434 | 96.12529727513947 | 5443.044418436746 | -44.820241016673585 | 104524.3565542988 | 26 | 43.21125247623613 | 69.15217318216074 | 9.80834460069814 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Long | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1923 | 83.620317613261 |
280 | Carbon Fiber | 169.79265005989234 | 0.3181057399937741 | 3362.6542808212753 | 707.4702996778867 | 72.86849252344486 | 15805.846416803606 | -42.39587478411417 | 165460.665629724 | 35 | 20.891434665572742 | 53.58689568172608 | 6.352011466468827 | Cylindrical | uniform | High | Long | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1770 | 62.191332570599485 |
281 | Titanium | 137.2350913713762 | 0.30449616861502515 | 3700.377606847798 | 717.2515849431023 | 67.28383439129476 | 7000.936857146653 | -53.829102244576404 | 105017.48288982283 | 25 | 46.83660047495542 | 48.46890965175308 | 13.387533006607555 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Medium | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 583 | 75.9612560910044 |
282 | Aluminum | 115.29300684919109 | 0.3184380080271858 | 4125.936865372625 | 1214.1966605504322 | 91.9454969747219 | 7274.916556316738 | -57.92185559036089 | 116390.37797121082 | 22 | 37.50186031484844 | 45.10950272161495 | 14.085511449205427 | Cylindrical | uniform | High | Medium | Poor | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1832 | 56.710819002829595 |
283 | Carbon Fiber | 176.52288232004204 | 0.3091817920483404 | 2793.7421284399325 | 396.6689811486299 | 53.33379524783018 | 9851.885901686885 | -40.098808281132484 | 164929.25085347675 | 22 | 56.62656363821458 | 64.65850890787505 | 9.476010096261849 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | High | Shark Optimizer | 1661 | 125.66561305686342 |
284 | Aluminum | 85.10311917589424 | 0.3250320128327853 | 2087.2738969767315 | 1174.0570532076674 | 50.79963359933059 | 7280.2239669761675 | -45.37169072002044 | 127537.77521433562 | 38 | 26.978441141393734 | 62.96134180275982 | 9.409737797277376 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Long | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1292 | 98.00597854028697 |
285 | Carbon Fiber | 189.53534555057416 | 0.3328902583943779 | 3966.9330507887244 | 305.0795095240535 | 81.16855226576678 | 10784.877875809436 | -43.41033189411002 | 151313.77588389887 | 22 | 25.065357519104342 | 54.81899072273649 | 11.264380748948248 | Rectangular | distributed | Low | Long | Good | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1600 | 147.29283875119353 |
286 | Titanium | 98.98609692431702 | 0.3497879572761305 | 2846.3715634561454 | 1206.0676752647596 | 74.2169437962935 | 17730.444488559784 | -42.704273269890095 | 161905.09035316168 | 34 | 52.675123915299324 | 37.662125736937256 | 12.653889059725028 | Rectangular | point load | High | Short | Good | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 634 | 145.33209330225165 |
287 | Titanium | 80.55784456890241 | 0.34976744997721654 | 3002.602605346025 | 1148.3674069036065 | 54.832538780004136 | 14987.596501108343 | -59.163533778771864 | 174311.15305892937 | 30 | 59.12129669914463 | 41.16695530622888 | 10.715935978925739 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Short | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 900 | 144.84186373443015 |
288 | Aluminum | 117.95200255027571 | 0.32767764039637065 | 2330.819769711209 | 553.7367917305155 | 90.47971352613263 | 19486.52817290716 | -54.61211019163627 | 195308.92606680357 | 32 | 49.46487274908121 | 55.539936400983045 | 12.230750280417084 | Tapered | uniform | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1369 | 139.42699771695612 |
289 | Aluminum | 155.8191615056037 | 0.31129332863287673 | 3161.7392868333454 | 922.1466928801116 | 67.17891880010666 | 16577.678484371798 | -48.89323682062665 | 181673.77104873906 | 22 | 58.78346866123343 | 34.4539775040142 | 7.717805892580085 | Rectangular | point load | Moderate | Short | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1271 | 86.86101488571046 |
290 | Carbon Fiber | 143.54675083662738 | 0.34174603205969084 | 3247.8831573619427 | 1476.9199519619747 | 76.7750227876111 | 11865.062747889351 | -56.81522176851152 | 107849.6697591146 | 27 | 37.82242821368178 | 51.67286343541725 | 9.722605819991728 | Rectangular | uniform | High | Long | Good | High | Shark Optimizer | 718 | 145.23687533121898 |
291 | Titanium | 148.50909668570117 | 0.30608664114719525 | 3884.2686994343203 | 1393.2456312777863 | 77.17624864015906 | 8401.037170388068 | -58.61992262154988 | 126779.1213749302 | 31 | 46.75099271250602 | 53.46373718528487 | 5.132143030452556 | Cylindrical | point load | Low | Short | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 797 | 80.20122112826833 |
292 | Titanium | 115.64807787707241 | 0.312168382931845 | 2269.4946797452067 | 1496.0900572156327 | 62.89137194278163 | 17516.761506200004 | -42.558844475029815 | 117237.22246613717 | 20 | 25.779021282469074 | 66.6939981592844 | 10.931995698857497 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Long | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1152 | 95.02410278716414 |
293 | Carbon Fiber | 152.19298113374987 | 0.30568797162727074 | 4029.6462356487896 | 715.818632174801 | 93.80331437640177 | 10520.244343647923 | -48.03315757848352 | 111051.17602928143 | 25 | 35.443337956795276 | 67.80255919793285 | 11.907901225962206 | Tapered | point load | High | Medium | Good | Low | Shark Optimizer | 820 | 132.30481689652333 |
294 | Aluminum | 117.36002445868198 | 0.3466053116773562 | 3006.1978261623835 | 480.98426539834946 | 61.33734779684961 | 12989.479632856071 | -42.00980007921311 | 130854.21620500425 | 31 | 20.986472780118888 | 62.58365570763588 | 11.90563308816559 | Tapered | distributed | Moderate | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1539 | 128.69087941551788 |
295 | Carbon Fiber | 125.24371041457647 | 0.3133765263406588 | 3683.252965646017 | 1014.2799956809547 | 82.41606800718073 | 18236.592028240142 | -41.40345922066663 | 115182.73614049428 | 37 | 26.054711379546106 | 66.3116976006136 | 11.899220672036083 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Long | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1522 | 55.32154775146428 |
296 | Titanium | 81.402076093447 | 0.31638075745070154 | 3532.958841127813 | 1391.7129968108009 | 94.40312171865794 | 8464.038664010153 | -42.28975119641002 | 119832.19496737808 | 36 | 23.2637976347783 | 40.887992208532324 | 5.188763578838172 | Cylindrical | point load | Moderate | Short | Poor | Low | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1092 | 80.86598043542074 |
297 | Titanium | 55.97896636848175 | 0.32687086647948893 | 2427.3951908379286 | 1054.9460378899175 | 59.26838448613375 | 9363.247661704849 | -56.90642121061366 | 169993.10115419654 | 24 | 27.56282087437862 | 52.3566153636087 | 12.13661289432569 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Medium | Excellent | Medium | Shark Optimizer | 1522 | 129.82292268067954 |
298 | Titanium | 181.4755039013556 | 0.33761911312864784 | 2529.2954311346416 | 532.2097956169976 | 87.36955621126728 | 15313.349255104666 | -40.149003561025566 | 168685.08257364627 | 26 | 22.145418294281455 | 30.684717832413945 | 11.543812957604953 | Cylindrical | uniform | Low | Long | Poor | High | Shark Optimizer | 594 | 51.89795828363507 |
299 | Aluminum | 106.47674007376429 | 0.3239004228536562 | 2295.3590690990013 | 705.3597184965945 | 62.55961649880683 | 14826.358818312372 | -48.31325985071068 | 125409.27772485602 | 23 | 26.87503151137357 | 55.76618939915603 | 8.521192075532527 | Cylindrical | uniform | Moderate | Short | Excellent | Low | Shark Optimizer | 1036 | 54.661268230527746 |
300 | Carbon Fiber | 112.79773948037523 | 0.3048648345978486 | 4062.0808391680516 | 619.8131697323777 | 97.60872566213848 | 12367.062895724015 | -53.50037607230469 | 153441.8260105037 | 39 | 31.012928898847136 | 39.55234336953571 | 13.36562092599181 | Rectangular | uniform | Low | Medium | Excellent | High | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1012 | 100.59953325652282 |
301 | Titanium | 150.11706063756958 | 0.34414444111197534 | 4238.370089472764 | 1259.170797541669 | 73.67445196167145 | 11749.799603298728 | -48.08308147277026 | 128124.36617500398 | 35 | 45.36454860814612 | 61.40523874868347 | 12.854248658142579 | Rectangular | distributed | High | Medium | Poor | Medium | Chaotic Quantum Genetic | 1830 | 114.71417920841427 |